Not that I watch the show. But from what i’ve read online, Taylor Hicks annoys me.
Oh yeah, first.
He’s much more talented, in my opinion.
TAYLOR!
CHRIS!!!!!!! Since he’s gone then I must pick Taylor. I don’t have “MacPheever”…not at all. Pretty face, but she’s fat and doesn’t sing all that well.
taylor
I agree, Chris would’ve been my first choice.
taylor!!
Onl;y 8 comments? Whoa anyways, I dpn’t watch it, but I’ll go for the one with thew coolest name, umm: Katherine?
taylor!
neither – american idol – what a waste of time. I don’t idolize any of those people.
Taylor Hicks
GOOBERS, both.
taylor hicks.
Taylor Hicks!
Don’t watch it, so I’m going to put my hand in the hat and pull out McPhee.
you can tell I don’t watch. My first reaction was, who are these people.
first page…….WHOOO!!!!! and Taylor all tha way
AMERICAN IDOL QUESTIONS? IF ANYONE WANTS ME ILL BE AT THE FUN QUESTION CAFE
I have missed some of American Idol, so you pick for me, my favorite of them all is Kelly Clarkson and Justin Guardinni from the Movie justin and kelly
They have such chemistry.
oh, and the show is stupid too. did anyone else ever see the rip-off WB did of AI? a couple of summers ago my brother and i used to watch it. . . they were trying to get the worst singers ever and have a crappy singer competition. I’ve never been able to find out what it was called . . . but yes, that was a decent show. unlike AI, where the talented people like Chris and Mandisa and Elliot and other people that got voted off a long time ago get voted off.
Let me be honest. I wouldn’t buy either of their CDs. But I’ll still watch it.
Taylor Hicks
Katharine
Taylor has the Ticks or Katherine McHo. what a choice. does anyone else wonder how in the world AI is going to market the winner?
who or what now?
Taylor even though i don’t even watch.
Duh….Taylor!!!
The Gray-Haired Fox.
I don’t watch American Idol, but look at him…
He’s fucking Taylor Hicks!
who or who? what?
I don’t watch the show, but from what I’ve seen I like them both…having to choose….I’ll go with Taylor Hicks because he seems to be older and finally following his dream.
Um Taylor Hicks. Katharine may be pretty, but she cannot sing. Actually Chris Daughtry will be better than all of them, but unfortunately, he’s off. So I am going for Taylor Hicks.
TV is overrated!!
ANSWER MY QUESTIONS OR YOU WILL GET AIDS AND DIE!
Taylor!
ANSWER HIS QUESTIONS OR HIS CAT WILL INFECT YOUR CAT WITH FELINE LUKEMIA AND ALL IT’S HAIR WILL FALL OUT AND YOU WILL HAVE NO RECOURSE BUT TO GO TO THE FUN QUESTIONS CAFE AND LEARN HOW TO KNIT A HAT FOR YOUR BALD AND DYING PET.
Don’t get me started.. but anyone BUT Katharine McPhee please.
Taylor!
Taylor
Katharine annoys me… too fake and choregraphed. Go Taylor!
Taylor Hicks
who?
sorry – i don’t watch that show.
i always vote for the lady…
Taylor!!
Taylor will win, doesn’t mean he should though. I’m still sad about Chris leaving But, I really think Katharine is more talented than Taylor, but there’s no way she’ll win.
I don’t watch it, but from what I have heard on the news, the gray haired dude
Kat
neither…chris should have won, and if american idol wasnt fake,he would have.
don’t care, don’t care, don’t care.
Neither. Both of them should go figure out what a real job is. :-p
TAYLOR!!!!
Who?
Taylor Hicks!
katherine. and who said katherine was fat? She is not fat, she actually looks like a normal human being!
katharine.
Hicks
Katherine is more classic, but a bit boring. Taylor’s not at all boring, but a little odd. It’s a toss up.
Taylor..
who and who? rawr. im to stupid.
Taylor!
Kat! She’s got an amazing voice…and since my top two are out of it… (Chris and Elliot)
Can’t watch Taylor and his goofy dancing. Dude looks like he’s either constipated or has to pee.
I’m with theabsolutpink. Katharine fat?? No wonder we have kids with eating disorders if people have some sort of warped idea that she’s fat. She’s gorgeous.
who?
Taylor Hicks all the way
taylor
You should have done this with a poll and had your own little Theologian’s cafe prediction of the winner. See how accurate the Xanga population would be.
Definitely Taylor
Hi, you seem like nice people, so will you kindly come to my site and answer my questions? I would ask more forcefully, but I’m not that sort of pushy, spam-wielding person. Please? Pretty please?
Regarding the post, I think I heard a rumor that Taylor Hicks likes to knit.
Since Chris is gone it has to be Taylor
TAYLOR!!!!
speaking of polls. . . dan, whatever happened to all the demographic information you got from us many, many posts ago? did you sell our highly confidential information?
oh, and these guys aren’t joking. they really want people to visit The Fun Questions Cafe. seriously.
Who?
Taylor all the way!
Taylor
definitely KATHARINE. she’s versatile, has an amazing range, and a gorgeous figure. Whoever said she was fat, screw you.
Taylor. I have to represent Alabama. I live there.
Didn’t watch until last week, so going just by their performances, Taylor looked like he was competing, while Katherine and the guy that got voted off looked like they were performing. Therefore, I’d have to vote for Katherine.
It’s too bad America votes on popularity rather than talent, though, so I expect Taylor to win.
Katharine McPhee. Althought Taylor is charming and theres something about him, but I gotta go with Katharine… CHRIS should have won though!!!!!
i have been trying to seperate myself from being influenced by the mass media idiocy of american idol. i like to watch mythbusters on wednesday nights instead. i think its pure lunacy that more people voted for that stupid television show than they did in the ’04 election. that is sad, my friend.that is very sad.
Chris was my choice, but now that he’s gone it’s gotta be Taylor!
Katherine. In terms of performance.
But really, Taylor has the better voice.
neither !
Taylor Hicks
TAYLOR!!!
neither
Neither! CHRIS was the ULTIMATE American Idol…everyone knew that.
Either
Taylor, he’s so much better.
Wow, I haven’t paid much attention to American Idol since Ruben Studdard (sp?) and Clay Aiken (sp?).
I really wanted Chris, but I’m going for Kat now! She’s not fat!
I have never seen an episode of American Idol in my life.
[ariana]
Have a GOOD Monday Dan…^^
Who???
Taylor Hicks.
but Chris should of WON it.
its rigged.
taylor!!
What’s up with all the spamming?
i think the fact that america watches that drivel, answers at least half of your last question…bush is definately speaking to a simple people…
definitely*
neither they are both HORRIBLE!! and IM AN IDOL FAN!!!! ugh…it should have been madesia and chris…but no!! Stupid America!! gosh!
chris but he’ll make it bigger then any of em anyway taylor =)
Taylor all the way!
Taylor!
Taylor
taylor
Katharine Mcphee is NOT pretty or talented.
Katharine
Chris Daughtry.
ohh i only watch that show in the beginning. so me and my family can lagh at the bad peaple and joke around. lool yes dan…were so crule
!~nicole~!
Chris Daughtry!
I can’t stand Taylor…
Go Katherine.
ugggghhhh taylor hicks makes me want to puke. he’s ugly and fat and looks like he’s constipated/brain damaged.
plus could you imagine him on a poster in a teeny bop magazine? no i think not. he’s not a pop star and never will be. ugh people make me so mad.
Mcphee all the way
huh?
I dislike the AI show on many levels. The promotion of people who haven’t paid their dues, so I only watched the auditions…and then watched other shows…
This year, however, is a little different. I choose Taylor because he paid his dues around the nation in small clubs and bars and other stuff for over 8 years…
He’s talented, a little goofy, and just an all around nice guy.
Katherine is pretty, but she tends to oversing songs…which shows a lack of performance experience.
So…when all is said and done…..Go Soul Patrol.
(I’m also sad that Elliot and Chris were voted off, they were both good too)
Let me say that again with more emotion, HUH?
I don’t watch American Idol. IDEA! You should have an Xangan Idol contest. It’d be cool.
I think Katharine has better vocals but…I think Taylor will win.
taylor
Who are they??
Taylor!!!! YAY!
even though I don’t watch AI…
Katharine!
people have wanted katharine out for a while…I say….TAYLOR
Katharine …I knew it the first night I watched.
Paris!….okay, okay…. K. McPhee…
Taylor
I couldn’t say, I don’t join the rest of America in watching that show.
kat has no range whatsoever. she only made it this far because she is really good looking. america has no taste, they voted off the most talented contestants already. i just hope taylor wins now.
Katherine all the way.
I don’t like Taylor.
I wanted Chris to win but he got voted off. I should have voted. This years season has been so good!
Ps. Taylor needs to dye is hair.
Taylor Hicks. . . of course.
McPhee. She’s adorable & would last. Props to Taylor for always doing his own thing though.
i dont know if you have ever hit this topic, but i think you should ask people what they think of the forwards such as the one i posted on my website. cuz it pisses me off and i wanna see if anyone actually likes them.
Taylor, his gray hair=instant win in my book
Taylor McPhee
Taylor -
TAYLOR. Katherine is such a rich, snobby girl.
TAYLOR DUUUUUH
Taylor Hicks =P
i liked Mandisa cuz she rocked but she left early
i guess taylor will win not that it matter now that Mandisa is gone
Taylor Hicks
Neither, considering I don’t watch the show. Honestly I think it’s a piece of crap. It’s called American Idol, right? So why are the contestants not role models, why is the show so popualr when it’s not, and what has become of our country?! It’s just sad.
Taylor without a doubt. I’ve been waiting for him to win since I saw him the very first audition.
-Jared
Haven’t watched since the auditions, so I can’t say I have the slightest clue.
Definately Taylor Hicks. Is that even a close choice? No. Taylor is way more talented then Katharine.
What a pointless question.
okay. first.
Kat.
and. the guy who said she’s fat….um. this is why we call guys pigs….it’s about her voice, and her overall appeal. also. she’s a size 3/4. i.e. not fat.
¿¿¿ wtf ???
Well, Chris was amazing but he’s gone. Katharine is a better vocalist but I think Taylor will win.
I don’t watch thath show and hopefully never will. So niether.:)
Taylor.
who cares. It’s one of the wrost T.V. shows ever made.
and the fact that he took his personality and made it to the end when all Katherine had was her looks (well and some talent singing) means a huge amount. i think he definately had the most ‘idol’ obstacles to overcome. she looks like an ‘idol’…i think that’s why he should get chosen. he’s different, and we need UNIQUE in show biz. its getting to be all the same.
Katherine… taylor has no talent, he just enjoys dancing around on stage. I think he should’ve been voted off a long time ago
I’d be lying if I said I didn’t want Taylor to win…. I am surprised that he has connected with “The Kids”….. I thought he only had old nerd appeal…
Taylor…
personally i liked the bald guy, but apparently he got voted off last week. so i’m going to switch from the bald guy to the old guy. taylor hicks.
Taylor.. (another Chris fan actually…) Katharine is pretty, she has a nice voice but nothing impressive. At least Taylor is entertaining
awww im sad i have no opinion on this one either…i dont have tv at the moment…it has crappy reception so i cant watch
katharinee!
Katharine!!!!!!!
Haven’t watched it, but the girl will win.
Taylor, but probably Katharine McWhateva!
Taylor!
Taylor all the way!
-elizabeth
that show stinks! I’ll never watch it again..
I think Katherine will win all the way. I got the Mcphever and so do a lto of people. America chose wrong thought by voting off Chris. I think Katherine will win. Taylor just enjoy’s dancing on stage and having grey hair. Katherine has the talent, looks, and everything .,She is the perfect idol!
taylor hicks all the way we dont need another girl i wanted elliot to will but that didnt happen!!!!!
I like them both…but I want Taylor to win more.
Chris should have won……
Ew. Now that Eliot and Chris are gone, I couldn’t care less.
Taylor!
dont watch it…sorry
KATHARINE MCPHEE NO DOUBT
HOPEFULLY Taylor Hicks…
CHRIS DAUGHTRY
i know he was voted off but he ruled way more than any of the other morons.
Katharine shows her boobs too much.
Katherine. Taylor isnt really “American Idol material” to me. He’s too…strange haha.
Both a very good. Katherine is gorgeous and not fat. Taylor will probably win and that’s fine, he’s really good. But when Elliot comes out with a CD that’s the one I’m going to buy. He’s a phenomenal musician. Too bad he’s off. Chris was never one of my favorites.
Katherine fat? That just proves my point that your beliefs create your reality.
Katherine Mcphee
Taylor, the soul man-he is mighty fine!
Katherine
Taylor!!!!! hes so much better than Katherine! shes fat, got a big butt, and cant sing! GO TAYLOR!
Taylor would win a personality contest, but Katharine sure can sing. I don’t know….
Who or who?
Who are these people? O.o
tayler sucks so macphee
I’ve never heard of either of those people
On MSN.com the vote is split right down the middle…50/50
Definetly KATHARINE!!!! She Rocks!
Taylor SUCKS!!!!
Taylor Hicks, definitely.
Chris… He’ll be the one to make it big.
But since someone has to win, McPhee — Taylor’s fun, but in the long run, he’ll be a one-hit-wonder.
I WOULD PICK McPHEE!!!!!
Katharine McPhee! Taylor Hicks is pretty good too . . .
katharine. taylor seems like he’s mentally retarded. or has some sort of a.d.d
Taylor cause he’s talented, Katherine cause she’s hot.
i have a mcpheever also… i adore her..
TAYLOR!!!!!
why ppl like taylor he can`t fcken even sing wun note i mean if yu like him dhen yur must be like 50 year old i don`t see why teenagers like him i mean he can`t sing so MCPHEE dhis is my opinion so don`t be bitching baq [;
though chris was AWSOME! i was voting for him.
Taylor, hopefully!
I don’t watch the show but…how about a tie?!
Hicks
mcphee!
Taylor Hicks.
*A*
Eh
I HATE TAYLOR. he is trying too hard to be funny.
Chris Daughtry all the way … but I’ll pick the less repulsive Katharine.
I love Katherine, I picked her as a favorite from auditions. But I have to say, Taylor will win.
I like myself a grey-haired man…….
Saw you on featured and I watch AI so I thought I would voice my thought… NEITHER!!! I would not buy either of their CDs. It was either Chris or Elliott for me.
Taylor, I guess. I didn’t watch american idol this season.
Neither. I’m still greiving over Bucky being kicked off weeks ago…
who them ?
american idol is so shittofied.
Chris. But since he’s no longer in the running, Taylor. Katharine can go back to the strip club.
Taylor is this year’s winner. Soul Patrol!
Don’t care.
chris was my fav but since he’s gone …
taylor
I think the only element that makes people like Taylor so much is that he is charismatic on stage. He gets the crowd going and is full of energy. Katherine seems to have a more mature singing voice…. I think Katherine should win because when they come out with a CD after winning, you wont be able to watch taylor dance around like a Jackass while listening to a CD.
more like CHRIS DAUGHTRY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! i’m tired of girls winning, especially ones that don’t get voted off after singingly poorly for a few weeks straight. TAYLOR HICKS.
singing*
taylor, even though he’s irritating.
he’s got charisma.
Taylor
Katherine
HAHAHAHAHHHA that just got my attention… hahaahah and yes… CHRIS!! hahahhaha no way he could have been voted off with such a HUGE fan base… not a chance… next question is… “is AI rigged?”
Jeff
I DON’T CARE!
L,r
TAYLOR!!!!!
Taylor. I love Katharine, but she just doesn’t have the personality/charisma that Taylor does. I don’t think it’ll even be close.
TAYLOR! SOUL PATROL!!!!!!!
Taylor. I’m tired of Katherine.
I think chris should be the winner in a surprise comeback!!
Don’t care, I like them both. They should do a duet. She can sit on the floor and he can do that spasmodic dancing thing.
i think Taylor Will win cause he’s the best!!!!!!!!
I don’t care who it is. I really don’t care for either of them. If I HAD to pick, I’d pick Taylor Hicks because he’s actually grown throughout the competition. Although the only things he does that really irk me are the dancing and the giddyness. He CAN’T dance and the giddyness really makes me sick and Katherine shouldn’t even be in the running. She should’ve went home last week. So, I guess I don’t care…all the good ones have gone…I don’t even know why the have the competition. most of the singers have disappeared. Carrie Underwood, Kelly Clarkson and Bo Bice (runner up) are the only ones that have stuck with it. Anyway, I vote I don’t care who gets it. The ones I liked have been voted off…
Randall
Yes, Jeff, American Idol IS rigged along with the NFL and even the Presidency !! It’s just a fact of life….Cheating is everywhere. But, Cheaters won’t always win…
Randall
KATHARINE BUT IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN CHRIS!!!
TAYLOR ALL THE WAY!!!!!
Katharine McPhee
Thnx for bringing up the subject of Armertican Idol, going on teh forums to wish the contestants best of luck
katherine allthe way comment back
TAYLOR! he has greyhair in his30′s
Taylor… McPhee has good range, but she’s too immature to know how to use it!
You mean I really can’t pick Elliott? He was better than both of the other two. Okay, If I must pick between those two, Taylor gets it, hands down. Katharine’s attitude annoys me.
Comments (276)
Mcphee.
TAYLOR!!
Not that I watch the show. But from what i’ve read online, Taylor Hicks annoys me.
Oh yeah, first.
He’s much more talented, in my opinion.
TAYLOR!
CHRIS!!!!!!! Since he’s gone then I must pick Taylor. I don’t have “MacPheever”…not at all. Pretty face, but she’s fat and doesn’t sing all that well.
taylor
I agree, Chris would’ve been my first choice.
taylor!!
Onl;y 8 comments? Whoa anyways, I dpn’t watch it, but I’ll go for the one with thew coolest name, umm: Katherine?
taylor!
neither – american idol – what a waste of time. I don’t idolize any of those people.
Taylor Hicks
GOOBERS, both.
taylor hicks.
Taylor Hicks!
Don’t watch it, so I’m going to put my hand in the hat and pull out McPhee.
you can tell I don’t watch. My first reaction was, who are these people.
first page…….WHOOO!!!!! and Taylor all tha way
AMERICAN IDOL QUESTIONS? IF ANYONE WANTS ME ILL BE AT THE FUN QUESTION CAFE
I have missed some of American Idol, so you pick for me, my favorite of them all is Kelly Clarkson and Justin Guardinni from the Movie justin and kelly
They have such chemistry.
oh, and the show is stupid too. did anyone else ever see the rip-off WB did of AI? a couple of summers ago my brother and i used to watch it. . . they were trying to get the worst singers ever and have a crappy singer competition. I’ve never been able to find out what it was called . . . but yes, that was a decent show. unlike AI, where the talented people like Chris and Mandisa and Elliot and other people that got voted off a long time ago get voted off.
Let me be honest. I wouldn’t buy either of their CDs. But I’ll still watch it.
Taylor Hicks
Katharine
Taylor has the Ticks or Katherine McHo. what a choice. does anyone else wonder how in the world AI is going to market the winner?
who or what now?
Taylor even though i don’t even watch.
Duh….Taylor!!!
The Gray-Haired Fox.
I don’t watch American Idol, but look at him…
He’s fucking Taylor Hicks!
who or who? what?
I don’t watch the show, but from what I’ve seen I like them both…having to choose….I’ll go with Taylor Hicks because he seems to be older and finally following his dream.
Um Taylor Hicks. Katharine may be pretty, but she cannot sing. Actually Chris Daughtry will be better than all of them, but unfortunately, he’s off. So I am going for Taylor Hicks.
TV is overrated!!
ANSWER MY QUESTIONS OR YOU WILL GET AIDS AND DIE!
Taylor!
ANSWER HIS QUESTIONS OR HIS CAT WILL INFECT YOUR CAT WITH FELINE LUKEMIA AND ALL IT’S HAIR WILL FALL OUT AND YOU WILL HAVE NO RECOURSE BUT TO GO TO THE FUN QUESTIONS CAFE AND LEARN HOW TO KNIT A HAT FOR YOUR BALD AND DYING PET.
Taylor. he’s the one with a voice.
EEEEEEEEELLLLLLLLLLLIIIIIIIIIIIOOOOOOOOOOOOTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT!!!
ouuuuuccccch.
JaneSkellington
I don’t care anymore.
Candy
I like Taylor but I think Katharine is “it”
taylor hicks. and by the way… do you ever comment people back? or is there just so many you never get to them all?
Cleaning all the bathrooms in Grand Central Station with my tongue.
Who? What?
Neither…I liked Elliot, Chris, and Paris… I don’t think anyone else deserves to win.
GO TO TheFunQuestionsCafe AND…UM…YOU GET THE IDEA. JUST GO THERE.
→ Taylor Hicks â†
Thanks, Dan!
Don’t get me started.. but anyone BUT Katharine McPhee please.
Taylor!
Taylor
Katharine annoys me… too fake and choregraphed. Go Taylor!
Taylor Hicks
who?
sorry – i don’t watch that show.
i always vote for the lady…
Taylor!!
Taylor will win, doesn’t mean he should though. I’m still sad about Chris leaving
But, I really think Katharine is more talented than Taylor, but there’s no way she’ll win.
I don’t watch it, but from what I have heard on the news, the gray haired dude
Kat
neither…chris should have won, and if american idol wasnt fake,he would have.
don’t care, don’t care, don’t care.
Neither. Both of them should go figure out what a real job is. :-p
TAYLOR!!!!
Who?
Taylor Hicks!
katherine. and who said katherine was fat? She is not fat, she actually looks like a normal human being!
katharine.
Hicks
Katherine is more classic, but a bit boring. Taylor’s not at all boring, but a little odd.
It’s a toss up.
Taylor..
who and who?
rawr. im to stupid.
Taylor!
Kat! She’s got an amazing voice…and since my top two are out of it… (Chris and Elliot)
Can’t watch Taylor and his goofy dancing. Dude looks like he’s either constipated or has to pee.
I’m with theabsolutpink. Katharine fat?? No wonder we have kids with eating disorders if people have some sort of warped idea that she’s fat. She’s gorgeous.
who?
Taylor Hicks all the way
taylor
You should have done this with a poll and had your own little Theologian’s cafe prediction of the winner.
See how accurate the Xanga population would be. 
Definitely Taylor
Hi, you seem like nice people, so will you kindly come to my site and answer my questions? I would ask more forcefully, but I’m not that sort of pushy, spam-wielding person. Please? Pretty please?
Regarding the post, I think I heard a rumor that Taylor Hicks likes to knit.
Since Chris is gone it has to be Taylor
TAYLOR!!!!
speaking of polls. . . dan, whatever happened to all the demographic information you got from us many, many posts ago? did you sell our highly confidential information?
oh, and these guys aren’t joking. they really want people to visit The Fun Questions Cafe. seriously.
Who?
Taylor all the way!
Taylor
definitely KATHARINE. she’s versatile, has an amazing range, and a gorgeous figure. Whoever said she was fat, screw you.
Taylor. I have to represent Alabama. I live there.
Didn’t watch until last week, so going just by their performances, Taylor looked like he was competing, while Katherine and the guy that got voted off looked like they were performing. Therefore, I’d have to vote for Katherine.
It’s too bad America votes on popularity rather than talent, though, so I expect Taylor to win.
Katharine McPhee. Althought Taylor is charming and theres something about him, but I gotta go with Katharine… CHRIS should have won though!!!!!
i have been trying to seperate myself from being influenced by the mass media idiocy of american idol. i like to watch mythbusters on wednesday nights instead. i think its pure lunacy that more people voted for that stupid television show than they did in the ’04 election. that is sad, my friend.that is very sad.
Chris was my choice, but now that he’s gone it’s gotta be Taylor!
Katherine. In terms of performance.
But really, Taylor has the better voice.
neither !
Taylor Hicks
TAYLOR!!!
neither
Neither! CHRIS was the ULTIMATE American Idol…everyone knew that.
Either
Taylor, he’s so much better.
Wow, I haven’t paid much attention to American Idol since Ruben Studdard (sp?) and Clay Aiken (sp?).
I really wanted Chris, but I’m going for Kat now! She’s not fat!
I have never seen an episode of American Idol in my life.
[ariana]
Have a GOOD Monday Dan…^^
Who???
Taylor Hicks.
but Chris should of WON it.
its rigged.
taylor!!
What’s up with all the spamming?
i think the fact that america watches that drivel, answers at least half of your last question…bush is definately speaking to a simple people…
definitely*
neither they are both HORRIBLE!! and IM AN IDOL FAN!!!! ugh…it should have been madesia and chris…but no!! Stupid America!! gosh!
chris but he’ll make it bigger then any of em anyway
taylor =)
Taylor all the way!
Taylor!
Taylor
taylor
Katharine Mcphee is NOT pretty or talented.
Katharine
Chris Daughtry.
ohh i only watch that show in the beginning. so me and my family can lagh at the bad peaple and joke around. lool yes dan…were so crule
!~nicole~!
Chris Daughtry!
I can’t stand Taylor…
Go Katherine.
ugggghhhh taylor hicks makes me want to puke. he’s ugly and fat and looks like he’s constipated/brain damaged.
plus could you imagine him on a poster in a teeny bop magazine? no i think not. he’s not a pop star and never will be. ugh people make me so mad.
Mcphee all the way
huh?
I dislike the AI show on many levels. The promotion of people who haven’t paid their dues, so I only watched the auditions…and then watched other shows…
This year, however, is a little different. I choose Taylor because he paid his dues around the nation in small clubs and bars and other stuff for over 8 years…
He’s talented, a little goofy, and just an all around nice guy.
If you want some other info…check out http://www.graycharles.com
Katherine is pretty, but she tends to oversing songs…which shows a lack of performance experience.
So…when all is said and done…..Go Soul Patrol.
(I’m also sad that Elliot and Chris were voted off, they were both good too)
Let me say that again with more emotion, HUH?
I don’t watch American Idol. IDEA! You should have an Xangan Idol contest. It’d be cool.
I think Katharine has better vocals but…I think Taylor will win.
taylor
Who are they??
Taylor!!!! YAY!
even though I don’t watch AI…
Katharine!
people have wanted katharine out for a while…I say….TAYLOR
Katharine …I knew it the first night I watched.
Paris!….okay, okay…. K. McPhee…
Taylor
I couldn’t say, I don’t join the rest of America in watching that show.
kat has no range whatsoever. she only made it this far because she is really good looking. america has no taste, they voted off the most talented contestants already.
i just hope taylor wins now.
Katherine all the way.
I don’t like Taylor.
I wanted Chris to win but he got voted off. I should have voted. This years season has been so good!
Ps. Taylor needs to dye is hair.
Taylor Hicks. . . of course.
McPhee. She’s adorable & would last. Props to Taylor for always doing his own thing though.
i dont know if you have ever hit this topic, but i think you should ask people what they think of the forwards such as the one i posted on my website. cuz it pisses me off and i wanna see if anyone actually likes them.
Taylor, his gray hair=instant win in my book
Taylor McPhee
Taylor -
TAYLOR. Katherine is such a rich, snobby girl.
TAYLOR DUUUUUH
Taylor Hicks =P
i liked Mandisa cuz she rocked but she left early
i guess taylor will win not that it matter now that Mandisa is gone
Taylor Hicks
Neither, considering I don’t watch the show. Honestly I think it’s a piece of crap. It’s called American Idol, right? So why are the contestants not role models, why is the show so popualr when it’s not, and what has become of our country?! It’s just sad.
Taylor.
TAYLOR TAYLOR TAYLOR
Katherine McPhee
Who?
Why don’t you write about something of substance?
Taylor!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Taylor baby… SOUL PATROL!!!!!!!!!
Taylor is more unique, but I bet McPhee will win.
Taylor without a doubt. I’ve been waiting for him to win since I saw him the very first audition.
-Jared
Haven’t watched since the auditions, so I can’t say I have the slightest clue.
Definately Taylor Hicks. Is that even a close choice? No. Taylor is way more talented then Katharine.
What a pointless question.
okay. first.
Kat.
and. the guy who said she’s fat….um. this is why we call guys pigs….it’s about her voice, and her overall appeal. also. she’s a size 3/4. i.e. not fat.
¿¿¿ wtf ???
Well, Chris was amazing but he’s gone. Katharine is a better vocalist but I think Taylor will win.
I don’t watch thath show and hopefully never will. So niether.:)
Taylor.
who cares. It’s one of the wrost T.V. shows ever made.
and the fact that he took his personality and made it to the end when all Katherine had was her looks (well and some talent singing) means a huge amount. i think he definately had the most ‘idol’ obstacles to overcome. she looks like an ‘idol’…i think that’s why he should get chosen. he’s different, and we need UNIQUE in show biz. its getting to be all the same.
Katherine… taylor has no talent, he just enjoys dancing around on stage. I think he should’ve been voted off a long time ago
I’d be lying if I said I didn’t want Taylor to win…. I am surprised that he has connected with “The Kids”….. I thought he only had old nerd appeal…
Taylor…
personally i liked the bald guy, but apparently he got voted off last week. so i’m going to switch from the bald guy to the old guy. taylor hicks.
Taylor.. (another Chris fan actually…) Katharine is pretty, she has a nice voice but nothing impressive. At least Taylor is entertaining
awww im sad i have no opinion on this one either…i dont have tv at the moment…it has crappy reception so i cant watch
katharinee!
Katharine!!!!!!!
Haven’t watched it, but the girl will win.
Taylor, but probably Katharine McWhateva!
Taylor!
Taylor all the way!
-elizabeth
that show stinks!
I’ll never watch it again..
I think Katherine will win all the way. I got the Mcphever and so do a lto of people. America chose wrong thought by voting off Chris. I think Katherine will win. Taylor just enjoy’s dancing on stage and having grey hair. Katherine has the talent, looks, and everything .,She is the perfect idol!
taylor hicks all the way we dont need another girl i wanted elliot to will but that didnt happen!!!!!
I like them both…but I want Taylor to win more.
Chris should have won……
Ew.
Now that Eliot and Chris are gone, I couldn’t care less.
Taylor!
dont watch it…sorry
KATHARINE MCPHEE NO DOUBT
HOPEFULLY Taylor Hicks…
CHRIS DAUGHTRY
i know he was voted off but he ruled way more than any of the other morons.
Katharine shows her boobs too much.
Katherine. Taylor isnt really “American Idol material” to me. He’s too…strange haha.
Both a very good. Katherine is gorgeous and not fat. Taylor will probably win and that’s fine, he’s really good. But when Elliot comes out with a CD that’s the one I’m going to buy. He’s a phenomenal musician. Too bad he’s off. Chris was never one of my favorites.
Katherine fat? That just proves my point that your beliefs create your reality.
Katherine Mcphee
Taylor, the soul man-he is mighty fine!
Katherine
Taylor!!!!! hes so much better than Katherine! shes fat, got a big butt, and cant sing! GO TAYLOR!
taylor
Fight Mental Illness Stigma
Taylor would win a personality contest, but Katharine sure can sing. I don’t know….
Who or who?
Who are these people? O.o
tayler sucks so macphee
I’ve never heard of either of those people
On MSN.com the vote is split right down the middle…50/50
Definetly KATHARINE!!!! She Rocks!
Taylor SUCKS!!!!
Taylor Hicks, definitely.
Chris… He’ll be the one to make it big.
But since someone has to win, McPhee — Taylor’s fun, but in the long run, he’ll be a one-hit-wonder.
I WOULD PICK McPHEE!!!!!
Katharine McPhee! Taylor Hicks is pretty good too . . .
katharine.
taylor seems like he’s mentally retarded.
or has some sort of a.d.d
Taylor cause he’s talented, Katherine cause she’s hot.
i have a mcpheever also… i adore her..
TAYLOR!!!!!
why ppl like taylor he can`t fcken even sing wun note i mean if yu like him dhen yur must be like 50 year old i don`t see why teenagers like him i mean he can`t sing so MCPHEE dhis is my opinion so don`t be bitching baq [;
though chris was AWSOME! i was voting for him.
Taylor, hopefully!
I don’t watch the show but…how about a tie?!
Hicks
mcphee!
Taylor Hicks.
*A*
Eh
I HATE TAYLOR. he is trying too hard to be funny.
Chris Daughtry all the way … but I’ll pick the less repulsive Katharine.
I love Katherine, I picked her as a favorite from auditions. But I have to say, Taylor will win.
I like myself a grey-haired man…….
Saw you on featured and I watch AI so I thought I would voice my thought…
NEITHER!!! I would not buy either of their CDs. It was either Chris or Elliott for me.
Taylor, I guess. I didn’t watch american idol this season.
Neither. I’m still greiving over Bucky being kicked off weeks ago…
who them ?
american idol is so shittofied.
Chris. But since he’s no longer in the running, Taylor. Katharine can go back to the strip club.
Taylor is this year’s winner. Soul Patrol!
Don’t care.
chris was my fav but since he’s gone …
taylor
I think the only element that makes people like Taylor so much is that he is charismatic on stage. He gets the crowd going and is full of energy. Katherine seems to have a more mature singing voice…. I think Katherine should win because when they come out with a CD after winning, you wont be able to watch taylor dance around like a Jackass while listening to a CD.
more like CHRIS DAUGHTRY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! i’m tired of girls winning, especially ones that don’t get voted off after singingly poorly for a few weeks straight. TAYLOR HICKS.
singing*
taylor, even though he’s irritating.
he’s got charisma.
Taylor
Katherine
HAHAHAHAHHHA that just got my attention… hahaahah and yes… CHRIS!! hahahhaha no way he could have been voted off with such a HUGE fan base… not a chance… next question is… “is AI rigged?”
Jeff
I DON’T CARE!
L,r
TAYLOR!!!!!
Taylor. I love Katharine, but she just doesn’t have the personality/charisma that Taylor does. I don’t think it’ll even be close.
TAYLOR! SOUL PATROL!!!!!!!
Taylor. I’m tired of Katherine.
I think chris should be the winner in a surprise comeback!!
Don’t care, I like them both. They should do a duet. She can sit on the floor and he can do that spasmodic dancing thing.
i think Taylor Will win cause he’s the best!!!!!!!!
I don’t care who it is. I really don’t care for either of them. If I HAD to pick, I’d pick Taylor Hicks because he’s actually grown throughout the competition. Although the only things he does that really irk me are the dancing and the giddyness. He CAN’T dance and the giddyness really makes me sick and Katherine shouldn’t even be in the running. She should’ve went home last week. So, I guess I don’t care…all the good ones have gone…I don’t even know why the have the competition. most of the singers have disappeared. Carrie Underwood, Kelly Clarkson and Bo Bice (runner up) are the only ones that have stuck with it. Anyway, I vote I don’t care who gets it. The ones I liked have been voted off…
Randall
Yes, Jeff, American Idol IS rigged along with the NFL and even the Presidency !! It’s just a fact of life….Cheating is everywhere. But, Cheaters won’t always win…
Randall
KATHARINE BUT IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN CHRIS!!!
TAYLOR ALL THE WAY!!!!!
Katharine McPhee
Thnx for bringing up the subject of Armertican Idol, going on teh forums to wish the contestants best of luck
katherine allthe way comment back
TAYLOR! he has greyhair in his30′s
Taylor… McPhee has good range, but she’s too immature to know how to use it!
taylorr hicks.
http://www.interwebgames.com
Taylor Hicks all the way. Soul patrol!!!!!
taylor hicks!
Taylor, baby!
Chris … sucks he is out..I guess Mcphee
McPhee!!!!!!
TAYLOR.
You mean I really can’t pick Elliott? He was better than both of the other two. Okay, If I must pick between those two, Taylor gets it, hands down. Katharine’s attitude annoys me.
Huh?
Who really cares, go do something with your life
who really cares, go do something with your life
Taylor Hicks. The Katharine boat is rigged!!!!
But Chris would’ve kicked both their asses…..