October 26, 2006
-
Grey’s Anatomy
Ladies: If you were Meredith, would you pick
Dr. McDreamy (left) or Dr. McVet (right)?
Men: If you were Dr. McDreamy, would you pick
Meredith (left in white) or Addison Shepherd (right)?
Ladies: If you were Meredith, would you pick
Dr. McDreamy (left) or Dr. McVet (right)?
Men: If you were Dr. McDreamy, would you pick
Meredith (left in white) or Addison Shepherd (right)?
Comments (231)
they’re both okay : )
Addison!
1) McDreamy
2) Addison
I want McDreamy and McVet. Why limit myself to just one?
< would like to point out that she is not BOTH a man and a woman, just bi.
Hehe good show Dan
meredith: vet. he’s perfect.
mcdreamy: addison. she’s cool.
Meredith.
I don’t watch much TV. I wouldn’t know.
Dr. McVet looks good though…
I don’t know, but man that show is DRAMATIC. It’s kind of addicting, though. But geez, always with the drama!
I don’t like the choices.
Buuuut in response to your question, based on looks alone:
1.) McVet
2.) Addison
Addison!!! She has the better hair. Grey’s is too stringy.
Not that I am a man, but that answer was talking from a man’s perspective.
1. Dr. McVet
2. Addison
I couldn’t pick off of just looks. =(
McDreamy
Definitely Dr. McVet. BUT if I were McDreamy, I wouldn’t pick either of these women. Neither is much of a catch.
Without knowing anything about them, I’d say McVet.
Dr. McVet… =)
McVet
Hmm… neither of them are that great…
Well…McDreamy of course
That show is addicting, and I don’t know why.
McDreamy.
mc dreamy, meredeth
McDreamy!
McVet
McVet
Oh, Mcdreamy of course…. Wasn’t tonight a repeat? Please tell me it was.
Meredith, but she’s not very good-looking…just less ugly than whoever that other one is…
I don’t watch the show, obviously.
Which one has bigger boobs?
MCDREAMY TIMES A MILLION.
and if i was a guy, meredith.
Id do them both but for keeps I’d pick Mc Vet…….but keep Mc Steamy on the side!!
Dr. McVet hes cute haha
and for a guy i would say Addison Shepherd
McDreamy
Why have one cookie when you could have two?
McDreamy.
Dr. McVet! Aha.
Dude on the right. I’m guessing somehow that’s the wrong choice, though… still, that’s my preference.
I like the Latino hottie in the background!!!
Dr. McVet. He has a kinder face… or something.
Meridith looks like Laurie Partridge and Addison looks like a young Dr. Crusher. Eww to both.
McDreamy?!? Because he’s dreamy?
McVet?!? Because he spays and neuters?
Why are they both Scottish? They look Irish.
haha.. my post actually talked about me being upset over the fact that they were repeats tonight!
I go with McDreamy!! I am also a fan of Meredith! but George is my Favorite! 
Addison by far.
Definately Meredith
Neither of them are that great…but if I had to, I’d pick McVet.
Both? ha
McVet has the better personality…And the more I look at him.. the more I find him attractive.. Out of the woman… I think they are both unattractive… but Shepard is better looking.
mcdreamy!
I hate that show!!! But totally McVet
1. Mc Vet: He has a more interesting face
2. Addison: She just seems more real.
Was just passing through…fun post.
McVETTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT
… without question or hesitation.
ummm i would stay single.
Although, given free range, George over both of them. Even though TR Knight’s gay. It’s cool, we can work on it =).
Isaiah Washington isn’t even in the running after that stunt he pulled. Psh! Actors.
free reign* Time for bed.
I’d pick McDreamy. However, I’d rather call the character Derek, as I hate using the word “dreamy” as an adjective.
And hell, I’d pick Addison. I’m obsessed with her character/Kate Walsh in particular (: I’m not lesbian (or bi, for that matter), but I do think that Addison is hot. Hehe.
Meredith
mcvet.
Mc Vet for the guys;
for the ladies, neither — they’re both horsefaces.
McDreamy.
off to go watch that now.
hahhh.
ellen pompeo is gorgeous
i would choose her in a second
(meredith)
Mc Vet…….
They’re both attractive…I guess I’d have to know them to decide.
The men look so much alike in the picture, it’s hard to tell. I couldn’t choose until I watched them smile and heard them talk for a few minutes.
McDreamy!!
He’s the one!
Glad the appointment went well…..
Dr. McVet….be still my heart
and Meredith over Addison
mcdreamy, even though mcvet is better looking
Dr. McDreamy and Addison.
McVet, hands down. looks and personality-wise on the show
i would have chosen mcvet. meredith is a dumbass for choosing mcdreamy. too much drama with him
1. McDreamy
2. Addison
I am so hooked on this show! I tape it and watch it later so I can first watch my other two addictions, which are Survivor and CSI: Las Vegas
McDreamy all the way!!!
Mc Vet
Never seen it
McVet… he’s the nice one.
And hot too. Well they both are, but McVet is the type to stick around after too…
Neither. The darker woman in the background looks more my type.
I say Dr. McDreamy looks better than Dr. McVet, so I’d have to go with the guy on the left.
I dunno, McDreamy just looks older, more mature, and like he has more depth.
(Or maybe it’s just because I’ve seen him before & I’ve thought about how attractive he was before.)
I’m attracted to older guys entirely too much… it limits all the nicer, sweeter guys that are younger.
& I’d say I’d go with Addison if I were a guy. It’s the hair & the eyes. x]
(Although I’m sad to say that because Meredith reminds me of myself…)
based on the pictures
Dr. McDreamy
I don’t watch the show though so I don’t really know anything about personalitys..
Note that I haven’t seen the show.
Okay, so Meredith should definitely go with McVet because he’s a good guy and didn’t cheat on his wife (like “McDreamy,” who makes me sick).
And McDreamy should go for hmmmmmmmm… let me think…. his wife!!!!
What is up with people glorifying such lack of morale these days???
eh, niether.
Is it just me, or do McVet and McDreamy look similar?
>>I pick McVet.
I’d have to saaaaaay.. Dr. McDreamy. But that’s only going by that one picture.
mcvet…….
McDreamy based on looks, McVet based on personality. And if I was a guy, I’d choose Addison. I think she’s a lot prettier, since they both have whorish tendencies.
I think the Mexican looking chick in the background is pretty hot.
Physically, McDreamy. Emotionally, McVet. I’m leaning toward McVet, I think…
mr. mcdreamy
yay
Gray’s anatomy – i’m a fan! as for the question … McVet’s more my type, I’d say.
NEITHER. I think they are both ugly.
And I hate that show. SO MUCH.
McDreamy. Meredith.
omg come on…McDreamy hands down.
I don’t watch Grey’s Anatomy, but I’ll go with Meredith.
???? We don’t get that show.
mcdreamy, addison.
haha nice one…..love the show! though this season focuses too much on love triangles and relationship stuff…
mcdreamy, addison.
haha nice one…..love the show! though this season focuses too much on love triangles and relationship stuff…
Addison is a cheater
Meredith is a dramatic drama queen
McDreamy is (according to the news) GAY!!
McVet still reminds me of Robin in Batman
…….Yet I am still addicted to the show
McVet
Hmm… I guess I would have to see them in action, since neither one of them is really appealing to me. I don’t watch TV on a regular basis because I get poor reception at my house (and I am too cheap to pay for cable). Well, that’s because I know I will not have the time to watch TV anyway. Heck, I’m still stuck at the beginning of Season 2 of Lost. I can only watch one thing at a time – and I go about it quite slowly.
Dr. McVet. I don’t actually watch the show though.
OMG!!! i cant decide,.. i just love greys anatomy!
Dr McVet.
mcVet ::sigh::
MCVET!!!!!! and Meredith.
As much as I hate Meredith’s wishy-washiness….. Derek’s wife cheated on him.
McDreamy, mos’ def.
And just to prove that I can judge the beauty of women and not have to be a lesbian (as seems to be the general consensus of the people that I talk to)… if I was a guy, then I would choose Meredith. She has a lovelier face.
1) McVet
2) Meredith
Good day to you!
The Mr and Ms Xanga Awards 2006 has just begun! Please come on over and cast your vote, partake, and help make this another interesting competition!
-whonose-
Meredith is soo whiny. Who does she think she is?
HI“
Knowing nothing about them or anything, the blonde one on the left.. Meredith, is it?
Though I don’t like either that much, honestly.
This is a little late, but I’m glad to hear your appointment had at least somewhat positive results. I would’ve been scared to go, too. Six months, a year, two years, whenever. Facing the possibility of your own mortality is a tough thing. I submitted to a voluntary HIV test when I found out I was pregnant. I’m not in any of the high-risk categories, but it was scary nonetheless.
they’re both ugly.
I’d pick McVet. McDreamy’s too much of a pretty-boy for me.
Neither women. They ain’t hot in my book.
’nuff said…
Any telly program writer that names a character Dr. McDreamy should be shot.
This is my all-time favorite show (well, along w/ heroes) but I would go w/ McVet, he’s more my type definately. I don’t go in much for the chiseled look, and besides, I learned a long time ago that a girl should never date a guy that is prettier than herself. Nothing good can come of that.
dr mcvet
btw, sophiabeene, none of the characters on the show are gay. the guy who plays george, not mcdreamy, is gay in real life.
ah what am i saying. ive never even seen the show
McDreamy!! I love him!
That is a really tough one. McDreamy is so beautiful, but McVet is, well, he’s beautiful too. And so sweet. The better choice would probably be McVet but I could see myself going for McDreamy. Heck, I’ll take them both. And if I were a guy I think I’d go for Addison. She’s a lot more confident and a lot less whorey.
Not to say that Meredith is completely whorey all the time, but she’s a tad too loose. Oh, but then you have that whole adultry thing with Addison. Hmm, I guess that’s not a good arguement…
Addison for sure!… McVet.
I wouldn’t have a clue…I’m one of the few that doesn’t watch the show.
neither…
Patrick Dempsey – in a heartbeat.
If I were a man, I’d pick Meredith before that stinking Addison. Yuck.
McVet! I LOVE me some Chris O’ Donnell!
I would choose McSteamy, but I’ll pick McVet out of the two given.
And I would pick Addison – Meredith is too skinny.
McVet. I can’t stand McDreamy.
McDreamy… hands down.
I am so sad it was a re-run last night!
McVet and Addison
neither dreamyor vet…neither look good…
and yes, i do watch the show (wheni get a chance…so i have NO CLUE whahts going on this season
o well)
Kelly
based on looks alone (I’ve never seen the show) I would pick McVet. McDreamy is too old.
McVet for me!
Neither guy is very attractive, but if I had to pick, it would be McVet.
1) McVet
2) I think Addison is prettier, but Meredith has the bigger heart
It probably only seems like meredith has the bigger heart though b/c all we hear throughout the show is her thoughts.
McDreamy. He’s got more personality, for one thing.
Meredith. I just want to see those two get together.
McDreamy is so much better looking than the other guy!!
mcdreamy
Meredith
1. mcvet
2. addison.
Oh, McDreamy, but that’s becuase I am like Meredith and pick men that are bad for me.
McDreamy is hot but McVet is probably the better man. If I were a guy I would become gay and choose McDreamy because Meredith and Addison are both screwed up in the membrane.
Once again, I sense some heterosexism here. What, do you think all men like women now, Mr. Lewis?
Mr. McVet because he was really goo dot Meredith.
And, if I was a guy I’d pick Meredith because at least they weren’t married when she cheated. And she is also more attractive.
Dr. McDreamy
I’d pick Dr. McVet, and if I were McDreamy I would pick Addison!!
neither.
is there a third choice?
McVet
Put your hands together…
Actually, I’d pick Meridith
if you like this show, than you’re a sucker for shitty t.v
Mc Dreamy~
Addison:)~
McVet and Addison
Dr. McVet. Yes.
McVet
McDreamy!! Just the look kills you.
If I was a guy, I think I might pick Addison. She has more passion in her soul and doesn’t whine as much.
1.McVet
2.None of them
McVet
based on just those pictures, McVet and Addison
Dr. McVet
McVet
ew.
Neither of those women are attractive. = |
McVet and Allison :]
*Addison, ooops.
I would pass on both Meridith and Addison and go for Izzy…
I’ve loved Chris O’Donnell since jr. high so I’ll have to go with Dr. McVet though I hope he’s not such a wimpy guy.
Why do both the girls look like crap at the hospital? I’d go with Addison probably.
Meredith.. definately.
Let me be the first to say that both of those men are far more attractive, than those women. And I’m not just saying that because I’m a woman. In general, I think there are far more beautiful women in the world than men. . .But those guys are both babes.
Definitely McDreamy.
mcdreamy for sure
Shepherd
Both are hot.
Mr. Mc Dreamy…yummy
I’d pick McDreamy. Though he’s proved he’s a cheater, he and Meredith will inevitably get it on again and again. If she went with McVet, she’d have a more secure relationship, but she’d probably end up gettin’ freaky with McDreamy. And McVet wouldn’t stand for it, which would cause depression, and perhaps a close personal relationship with McDonald’s.
the girl in the middle
McDreamy, shouldnt have to ask
Don’t watch the show but, McVet. He’s cute.
< Would also like to point out she is bi, not both woman/man
1. McDreamy
2. I am tooooo much like Addison. Not kidding, red hair, blue eyes, has issues.
Meredith. Messed up in less malignant way.
Greys Anatomy! I love you.
Anyway, McDreamy. Adurr.
Hey.
Wheres McSteamy?
Mc Vet is cuter. Think the show is stupid though.
McVet please.
i would pick the one on the right.
Neither. But McVet if I had to pick one.
Dr. Mc DREAMY!!
Mc freaking Vet!!! I love the fact the he is so nice to her….but you know in real life, women tend to go to the guys who make them cry. Damned if I know why.
McDreamy!!
I think both of those men are hidious. But if I had to choose, I’d pick the one on the right.
-KrIsTiN-
McDreamy. And it’s addicting because there’s someone that each viewer can personally relate to…. if you aren’t meredith, you certainly know someone like her – same thing goes with george.
Ash
McDreamy, in a heartbeat. Everyone can say McVet but once you meet your McDreamy…there’s no contest.
mcvet.
Neither.
McVet based on the picture alone, but I’ve never seen the show
McDreamy
Out of the two…
McVet.
dr. mcdreamy… hands down
McNeither..I would go with George.
Meredith should have picked McVet (Finn) – she made a stupid mistake choosing McDreamy and his McBaggage.
McVet, no doubt.
Mmmm Dr. McDreamy, even though I don’t watch Gray’s Anatomy. Yet.
Dr. McVet
McDreamy of course..and it would have to be Meredith.
mcdreamy
McDreamy if I was a girl.
Meredith since I’m a guy.
I FUCKING LOVE ADDISON.
and deffintely, mc.dreamy. what a hottie..
yum.
McVet and Addison.
I don’t really watch this show, but whatever.
McDreamy! The hottie of the year.
Mr. McVet
DR.MCDREAMY!!!~
cause he has this auora about him~
DR MC VET! sooo cute =]
1. Finn. I like nice guys.
2. Addison. I’m sure that I would have better conversations with her.
I hate how the characters are always repeating things. It’s so annoying! That ferry boat scene (with Dr. Shepherd and Meredith) drove me nuts.
Neither. I’d choose Dr. House.
Mc Vet
But they both look the same
your right or my right? just checking
1) I’d pick McDreamy hands down!!!
2) And if I were a guy, I would pick…Izzie! Because Meredith whines way too much! And Addison isn’t very faithful…and well, Izzie can cook!!! and bake!!
Technically neither, but Mcvet seems too nice, and i wouldn’t want to mess him up.
My husband said he likes Addison better.
Dr. McVet.
Hes a dog guy.
oh yeah and id definately pick Meredith… Addison is a beeyotch. :/
McVet
oh la laaaa McVet.
Both girls are ugly.
…I’m a lesbian.
Eh, neither
Oddly enough, I don’t find either of the guys very attractive, personally
Oh well
thats a very homophobic thing for you to say.
what about women who like women???
or men who like men???
definitely mcdreamy. he’s the original, he’s scrumptious looking and he has an infectious grin.
something about mcvet irks me.. i don’t know what it is. thankfully, he is no longer an issue. =]
Addison all the way. She’s gorgeous.
McVet. he’s more hot