May 20, 2010
-
Is The U.S. Better Than Other Countries?
The Texas Board of Education is working on the textbooks that students use in school.
One issue that is coming to the surface is “American Exceptionalism.” American Exceptionalism is the idea that the “United States, by virtue of its orgins and ideals, its struggles and accomplishments, stands apart from –and, in some eyes, above — other nations.”One author claimed, “From childhood, we are indoctrinated with the propaganda that America is superior to other nations; that our way of life, a mass-market ‘democracy’ manipulated by lobbyists, is superior to all other forms of government.” Here is the link: Link
Do we tend to think we are better than other countries?
Comments (189)
Yeah, and with little reason.
Just look at Sandinavia, Sweden, etc.
Without a doubt.
Yes.
Nope.
Bloated ego and unearned contentment should be replaced with humility and hard work.
How is America NOT better than everyone else? As Talladega Nights said, “We created the Missionary position!”
I think so.
@aznspartan94 - ^Joke
Yes !!!
Yes, and it’s not right at all.
I would point you to Northern Europe specifically as examples of much better nations economically, socially, philosophically and morally / ethically.
yes
French and Americans have elitist attitudes.
Like my father and I discussed about ten years ago when he moved back from Tblisi, Georgia, most people around the world all share a lot of common concerns.
I am not a nationalist. I consider myself human first and American second.
Yes we tend to think that way, but it’s false in my mind. I want to live in either Sweden or Germany!!! They are much better countries than the US for many reasons in my opinion. Unless of course the US drastically changes and yet I don’t really see that happening in the near future.
Most of them by a long shot but that is not to say there are not other wonderful countries as well
Every country teaches that. Maybe that is the cause of a lot of conflicts or at least misled ideas.
And yes. You Americans think you can go taking out Us from words like Colour and sticking Z’s where S’s belong. Who gave you the right?
@HappyLemming - Brilliant comment.
Of course we think we’re better. But are we? No.
Yes we do.
And no, we shouldn’t.
We do, but we shouldn’t.
Yes we do.
YES.
I am an American, and though I dislike what is going on in the country at present, I love my country. I think this hatred for our own nation is absurd, no, utterly depraved given the sacrifices made to found and protect it.
I’m Canadian and love many people in the states. It sometimes saddens me to see the state of affairs you people are in though. We could send a High School grad down there to teach in your schools. America is fucked up, – you’re about 10 years behind the rest of the world in my opinion and, I really am biting my tongue saying that
The US is a very unique country, no doubt about that. However I dont know if any country is ‘better’ than any other. It all depends on what you are comparing.
It depends on what we’re talking about.
America has done more to advance civil and human rights then any other country in recorded history.
If you’re talking about an equitable distribution of resources, then no… ’cause we ain’t commies.
No. New Zealand ftw!
yes. drives me crazy. sure, a lot of countries think they’re the best… but what’s with that? just makes excuses for wars more convenient and palatable. and the u.s. is way down there on a lot of the rankings like education and health care. which are kind of big deals.
Not in the ways that count.
Certainly more privileged, but I don’t know that that’s better.
We probably do, but we probably aren’t. We have the highest national debt in the world right now. It’s kinda sad, really.
@HappyLemming - Yes to that 1000 times over. There is a big difference between confidence/pride and entitlement/ego.
Yes. Despite all of America’s flaws I love my country.
Americans believe in American exceptionalism like Romans believed in Roman exceptionalism.
Marcus Aurelius seemed to see past it; his writings reveal him to be jaded and cynical concerning supposed Roman “superiority”.
Yeah, definitely. I was taught as a child to think anything other than democracy is wrong. I obviously don’t think that, but it definitely proves a point. We’re being taught that unless countries do things exactly like we do (or how we want them to) they’re inferior. It’s sad, really.
I think the better question is, how many people have actually been out of the country to have an opinion based on something beyond opinion/bias.
I don’t think that we are better, we can definitely still improve in some areas. I do know that we aren’t as bad off as some unfortunate third-world countries though.
But I do agree that American children are taught that the only good type of government is ours. And that all others are wrong or strange to us.
Dan for President! That’ll fix everything.
The overwhelming majority of comment on this post reject the idea of American exceptionalism, thus showing a virtue: Americans – at least on Xanga – have the ability to criticise their own culture, which is a virtue in any culture.
Yes, and it’s true. That’s why we live here.
I don’t understand the current trend of hating our own nation. It’s bizarre.
Certain other countries are better in every way. Better education, better health care, better social equality, etc.
I think Americans are largely spoiled children. We want what we want and we don’t care what other people have to go through to give it to us. We abhor people trying to show us what messes we cause…
I hear the swiss have it pretty nice…
@Unstoppable_Inner_Strength - *Scandinavia, and Scandinavia is not a nation, it’s a region.
You are ON IT the last few days. I can hardly keep up with all your posts and the opinions of all the comments
It’s the “We’re number one!” people who prevent improvements of the country. Ironic, considering those are the most vocal self-declared patriots.
I love my country (USA) but I don’t think we should teach we are better. I think children should be taught to respect their country and love of their heritage as an American and whatever other cultures they are decedent from.
HELL no.
Even with the goings on in Government we are still overall the best. Yes we have things to improve on. The second best is Britain.
do we think we’re better than other countries? yes. are we? no
@dikdoktor - that’s because American school systems are overrun with liberals who are entrenched.
I think we do because we tend to only learn what’s great about (and what’s going on) in our own country.
Difficult to get a perspective if you don’t know what the other ones are like.
A lot of Americans like to think that we are better than other countries….but we are not. Fucking egotistical bastards.
Yup, we’re the greatest.
The United States used to be great when it’s people were great. When we started to cater to the selfish and the lazy and the greedy we started to decay.
We do… but we are far from it. There are countries that are much happier than we are… and I consider those to be “better”.
Yes. We are rich and we will nuke you all.
One hundred percent yes. We think we’re fucking awesome. And we’re pretty awesome, but we’re also pretty unhappy and have skewed viewpoints. There are a lot of other really nice places out there and I don’t think we’re the best.
@JosephParsons - Agree.
Your country IS awesome, but I wouldn’t say it’s necessarily “better”. Though, Americans tend to think that they’re superior to everyone else.
Americans tend to think so, yes. myself, I’m ambivalent about it.
Yes you do.
@colonialgrl - I couldn’t agree more
I love this country. 100% proud to be an American.
Hong Kong is better, and it’s not even a country.
Plus, the U.S doesn’t have robots and it’s populated by red-neck fundies.
Most countries > America.
I definitely think we teach our children that America is the best country.
I think most people abroad would say their country is the best as well. Everyone has the right to love their country.
This is definitely the case!
Yes.
as a canadian living in america, my friends definitely have some idea of supremacy going on in their heads.
Hmm… We took Europe’s ideas, “reappropriated” America’s land, stole a population from Africa, and then made enough money off all of that to buy Asia’s materials. We’re unenthusiastically #1!
Yes, but I don’t think America is alone in that.
America is the best country for me, but I don’t think there is such a thing overall as a “best country”.
yes and you really see it when you travel overseas.
Yeah, a lot of Americans are really arrogant when it comes to comparing our country to others. And with little reason to be so arrogant. We’re a good country but I don’t think there is a best country. There is a difference between loving your countries and being arrogant.
I love how the state that wants to change the textbooks so they make other countries look worse history wise and so they put America on such a high pedestal is the same state that only joined because it absolutely couldn’t afford to be it’s own country, the state that has it’s own pledge of allegiance that is supposed to be said along with the American pledge of allegiance in schools, and the state that talked a lot about seceding last year.
Yes we do, and yes, we are. Who does the rest of the world come running to for help in times of economic peril, war, etc.? The United States… of course this notorious cycle of meddling in others’ affairs originated from interventionist international policies, but no one has stopped the US thus far, and there seems to be a general consensus that America IS the “best” nation in the world. If not, why would the other leading world superpowers simple watch idly while we intervene in numerous world conflicts? It seems the only people that have a problem with America and the superiority complex of her citizens are extremist Muslims, and obviously no one wants them around. But I digress, if we’re not the best, then SAY SOMETHING through some form of international policy (I’m not talking about one random Canadian or South African but the actual respective government) instead of receiving aid, calling when you’re in trouble and simply watching as we stick our nose in everything!
America is alright but I wouldn’t mind moving to different country. You can’t deny we have done a lot for the world… for better or worse.
Everyone thinks their own country/way of life is the best. It makes the US no different than other countries. Unless you’re like me, and you don’t really care. I’m an American and American is great and all, but I really don’t have this huge love/attachment to my country.
Yes. But then again, we’ve always thought we were better than other countries… I don’t think it’s a unique idea in general, actually.
Well hell yeah.
i dont, but if i believed what we learned in school i would.
Better yes, but going downhill, especially morally and spiritually
The U.S. is superior to many other countries in many respects. My impression of late however has been that the U.S. is gradually slipping towards an inferior national dynamic more so characteristic of the nations of Latin America.
@AnExplicitAdventure - they watch idly because we have a big economy…and big guns. There are plenty of other countries aka. venezuela, cuba, that have plenty of problems with us. it’s not just extremist muslims. From the perception of much of the world, we’re intruders (Europe especially Great Britain), or annoying big brothers that stick their nose into other people’s business, they don’t intervene because of our military power and economic stronghold.
America at the moment is a little chaotic. Okay fine America is a mess right now but I still love my country. American people once used to be taught to be the best and our children were successful. However, our current generations, are not as smart when compared to students from across the globe. Our educational system needs to be polished and scrutinized because otherwise the future children will be screwed. Jonathan Kozol has many great works about the current state of the American educational system. you should check it ou!
UK all the way.
Yes, America thinks it’s top s***, when it isn’t. In my opinion, other countries are more honest about what freedoms they give their people than here. For example, a post from Aaliyaan gave his reason about why he moved abroad and is happier in Portugal for religious reasons, and I don’t blame him. (if I could find the link, I’d put it here). The culture here is poor. People are rude. American beer sucks.
I moved to America when I was 5 (from Australia) and I’ve been here for almost 16 years. I also have parents who were both originally from modern-day Serbia. I’ve been planning my escape from this place since I was ten (now I’m going to graduate school in Prague next fall, then staying there), so that tells you what my opinion is of America. I’m revoking my American citizenship as soon as I obtain another citizenship elsewhere. I went to Europe last summer and even though I only identify myself as Slovak and Australian, my accent betrayed me and I got a lot of shit for being an “American” (thank you, accent) there. I heard from a lot of Europeans how they think Americans are too snobby and up themselves. I even talked with my parents one night, and they said that if we hadn’t been guilt-tripped into moving here, we’d still be in Australia. They don’t like it here either. Heck, you know it’s bad when my dad thinks Yugoslavia was a bit better of a place than here (and he lived there under Tito) :p
@OhItWontBeForever - LOL. Yeah, I don’t get it either… I use the UK spelling, it’s better
BOY, I SURE HOPE SO !! ONCE WE LOSE THAT WE’RE F****ED ! THERE IS SOME TERRIBLE SHIT COMING OUT OF THE WHITE HOUSE LATELY !
@Rhia_Pyrithea - I guess you’re my only friend this time
Living in another country has shown me how important being an American is. People want to know me over someone from Canada or South Africa because I’m American.
I love how people say we shouldn’t judge other countries, and then proceed to bash America. America has screwed up, but overwhelmingly we have done more to advance and help humanity than any other nation. The assembly line, foreign aid, medical advancements, the internet, the (agricultural) green revolution, etc. Does that make other countries “worse,” give an excuse to have an inflated ego, and you MUST think it’s the best? No…but be at least a little bit appreciative. Fuck. Some people are making it sound like it’s pure torture living here.
It would only make sense to move somewhere else if you find it much too shitty for your liking. I know it sounds like the whole over-the-top “love it or leave it” statement, but why wouldn’t you go somewhere else you view exponentially more awesome?
So do I think it’s the best? It depends on what we’re talking about…
Yes…but I’m Canadian and therefore heavily biased on this subject…
The people that appreciate America the most understand how awful other countries are. Not necessarily in terms of military power and advancement, but in terms of human rights and safety. I like being able to go to sleep every night and not having to worry about crazy foreign troops shooting at my windows, thank you very much, as well as the lack of religious police.
In general, prolly. We do like to impose our ideas on other people, anyway.
I think lots of different places in this world have their pros and cons.
man! people are d*****, and no, they are not better, wanna find out, check out other countries and not the poor ones mind u
Yes, you tend to think that, but no, it is aboslutely not true.
That implies that there is a standard for what is best and what is not, but I don’t think that’s true at all. What may be great for one person may not suit another.
In the middle
Many countries are full of arrogance. But do not confuse arrogance with pride. As an American, I do not think America is "better", we have our problems like everyone else. However, I enjoy our freedoms and all the culture we are exposed. I live in the American Northwest, and when I visit the south people think I stack simply because I'm from the city. I am sorry your stay was not funny. Maybe if you visited a different city, a place more tourist friendly? Like other countries there are parts of America that are not friendly toward tourists.
I think we are better than most, and possibly on par with others in various categories ^^. The only Americans that say otherwise have something they got to sell which price is much greater than its actual worth…I’m not buying. Our ideals separate us from many countries. There are others who also worked hard for freedom, so we should respect them as well. Consider them our brothers and sisters. We have our problems too, but the benefits greatly outweigh them. If some other country doesn’t like that, they can get in line and complain to someone who cares ^^ lol
@AubreyBird - So say if a guy likes personal liberties is on a bench somewhere, where you can choose to be who you want to be, with your personal values being the standard. And another guy sitting next to him prefers totalitarian rule, where the guy with the gun gets to choose who you are…its just one opinion vs. another opinion, one having no more or less merit than the other?
I would suggest reconsidering that. It is as intellectually bankrupt as it is morally bankrupt. Sure there is a standard, ask anyone who has lived under the rule of an ironfisted tyrant (whether that tyrant be one man or many men), and has decided to flee to a place where he is free to decide themselves what life they want to lead, I am sure they would have a far different story to tell. My intention isn’t come come down hard on anyone, but I just feel compelled to challenge that ^^
of course not! and I am currently living in the US, too.
Visit my site if y’all have the chance! subscribe if ya like!












crystal @ watermoolen
yes
Nope
If you mean working on textbooks for students you mean those crazy Texan idiots are putting a conservative spin on history then yes, that’s exactly what they’re doing.
The Texas Board of Education is working to eliminate the liberal bias in it’s social studies books.
It’s ridiculous. But that’s a different rant for a different day.
But yes, we do tend to be indoctrinated with the idea that as Americans we are better then everyone else in the world. It is that very idea that has caused much of the world to hate us.
or rather what it claims is a liberal bias.
I’m from Europe, and I like it here, I think we have some very nice things here and some very good policies and governments, I am sure other continents have the same but just in different ways. I don’t really think anyone place is better than another, it’s just what works for the individual.
America is the country that invented the modern democracy, helped win World War II, and put a man on the moon. But those are all past generation’s work. What has America’s current generation done? Scream at each other while China takes over the world. I’d say the U.S. *was* better, but that won’t last much longer. Not while Chinese students are actually being taught in their schools, unlike apparently students in Texas.
@Unstoppable_Inner_Strength - Look at Sweden for… how NOT to run a country? In what bizarro world is Sweden the model of anything other than an oppressive government?
@jwfarns - great comment!!!
it’s not..and that’s why I’m shipping my children to boarding school in england. Fuck american public education system..and I don’t care if we have to be dirt poor..I will never feed the bullshit that America is the best country in the world, but it’s not. Of course, I’m a human/person first then lastly an american. I treat everyone the same..treat every country the same. Of course, I’m not like everyone else…
so i don’t believe in all that America is the best bullshit…=/ sorry.
+input this URL:
( http://www.tnta.us)
you can find many cheap and fashion stuff
(jor dan s-h-o-e-s)
(NBA NFL NHL MLB j-e-r-s-e-y)
( lv h-a-n-d-b-a-g)
(cha nel w-a-l-l-e-t)
(D&G s-u-n-g-l-a-s-s-e-s)
(ed har dy j-a-c-k-e-t)
(UG G b-o-o-t)
WE ACCEPT PYAPAL PAYMENT
YOU MUST NOT MISS IT!!!
+input this URL:
( http://www.tnta.us)
you can find many cheap and fashion stuff
(jor dan s-h-o-e-s)
(NBA NFL NHL MLB j-e-r-s-e-y)
( lv h-a-n-d-b-a-g)
(cha nel w-a-l-l-e-t)
(D&G s-u-n-g-l-a-s-s-e-s)
(ed har dy j-a-c-k-e-t)
(UG G b-o-o-t)
WE ACCEPT PYAPAL PAYMENT
YOU MUST NOT MISS IT!!!
@Unstoppable_Inner_Strength - Just look at Scandinavia???? Do you know that Norway is noted as the country with the highest standard of living worldwide? In Norway you do not need health insurance to have equal opportunity to medical care. Get a clue before you blurt out uneducated nonsense.
This said, no country is perfect and perhaps we all just need to be a little more humble and open to change and the idea that maybe, just maybe, someone else does know better.
this shit is why Im homeschooling my son for as long as possible. Who the hell says Texas gets to determine the curriculum for the rest of the nation?
And yeah, we tend to be ego-maniacal twits.
@OhItWontBeForever - Not really.
/Here we somewhat have a bit of a defeatist anti patriotic attitude cemented by political division.
We’re not taught that Malta is epic. We’re taught that party X or party Y is epic.
In general, yes. The US tends to have an unwarranted elitist attitude. As do the British. As do the French.
@SheepShot - I dunno. I live in Britain and we were never taught that Britain is the best. haha. But maybe.
you may not consider america to be the best, but it is far from the worst. i think it’s good to raise out children to value what they have. what would happen to this country if we were all raised to believe all these other countries were better than us. everyone would develop this inner hatred for themselves and their neighbors. then we would be well on our way to becoming the worst.
In other words, brainwashing?
This is the kind of mentality that allows corrupt governments to get away with anything.
I think my country is better! Poland of course ;] Probably every person living in democracy will say sth in this way. I can say more: in every country – not only democratic ones – kids are teach to love their fatherland. This is the one of reasons why we had literature and history in schools. We learnt them not only to be able to memorise some things. They giving not only knowledge but also feeling of being part of a nation.
Well, I’m English, and we’re not taught that England is somehow better than any other country :-/ we’re just…taught. Sometimes England comes out on top because that’s how it was, but we’re also taught that England isn’t perfect and that there were times when we failed.
I generally see a horrible attitude from American’s (Not everyone) – that America is this amazing country that everyone should aspire to move to. Uh, no thanks. I would absolutely hate to live in America. Give me Europe any day, please.
@OhItWontBeForever - haha I just posted something similar then I read your comment!
We’re definitely not taught that Britain is the best here.
@individually_surveys - haha, I just saw your comment!
Like, we get taught the history and stuff, but that’s it. We never get taught we’re special in any way.
Not anymore, but 50 years ago… fuck yes.
Yes.
It’s nice to sleep safely at night, no bombs and such, i mean when was the last time a war was fought on our grounds? civil war? And yes i like that i won’t be executed for having pre-marital sex and i can protest whatever in the world i want to, but NO we are NOT the best. What have we done lately? America is a selfish, obese, greedy, i don’t give a shit, whore of a country. I think we all know this. Most of them are giant children, i don’t blame any other country for hating us, just so long as you don’t hate all of us =)
@OhItWontBeForever - haha exactly.
I’m studying in France too, and there is a little bit of the idea that “France is amazing”, but they do admit their faults also (maybe it’s different in schools – I’m at university), but I don’t think it’s anywhere near as bad as in America – everything in textbooks is balanced.
AMERICA, FUCK YEAH.
Common sense is the first casualty of arrogance!!!!!
Discussing his belief in American exceptionalism, President Obama said
last year, “I think that we have a core set of values that are enshrined
in our Constitution, in our body of law, in our democratic practices,
in our belief in free speech and equality, that, though imperfect, are
exceptional.” But he added, “the fact that I am very proud of my
country and I think that we’ve got a whole lot to offer the world does
not lessen my interest in recognizing the value and wonderful qualities
of other countries, or recognizing that we’re not always going to be
right, or that other people may have good ideas, or that in order for
us to work collectively, all parties have to compromise and that
includes us.“
No, I don’t think most people in the U.S. take this idea seriously. What most people in the U.S.take seriously is the idea that most Americans think America is exceptional.
We’re better at exploiting people, races, and nations.
i think that every country thinks they are better, for example i am british and believe we are way better than americans.
I do believe that we think we’re better than everyone else, but that’s just nationalist pride, and it’s not just Americans who experience it. And I also think there’s a difference between hating your country and hating its government; people need to learn the difference.
The US is no better than any other country and it pisses me off that I was taught from a young age that the US is superior to all countries. It took me till my college education to realize that the US is no better, and in fact, worse than other countries.
Yes, mainly cause it is true.
@Lordv16 - Very good point sir!
Anyone who thinks we are ‘better’ needs to start thinking critically.
@SpokenThruScott - Truth.
@JosephParsons - ’”America has done more to advance civil and human rights then any other country in recorded history.” Uh, what? All our “advancements” in civil rights is giving back what people had denied, which they were not denied in other countries. England ended slavery about half a century before we did, and I would wager that race relations in the UK are far better than they are in the US. The US has done a lot to stamp out civil rights (gay marriage and health care being the key issues right now, and many more in the past) that we need to acknowledge before you applaud the US for advancing civil rights.
Wholesale 2010 Ladies and Men Garment, Clothing, Shoes, Caps, Sunglasses: Homepage: http://www.21shtrade.com
Topbrandswholesale Wholesale and Retail Nike series shoes available:
Air Force1, Air max, Air Yeezy, Nike Dunk, Nike Free, Nike Run, Nike Blazer, Nike Rift, Nike James, Nike Kobe, Nike Football, etc
Original packaging with all cards and tags
Big discount for big orders!! Your satisfaction is our goal!!
If you are interested in any of our products, please contact us for details or to place your special orders.
Reach us
Contact Person: Mr Tony (GM)
Email:shtradetony@hotmail.com or shtradevivien@hotmail.com
MSN ID: shtradetony@hotmail.com or shtradevivien@hotmail.com
Yahoo ID: tonycs1978@yahoo.com
Skype ID: shtradetony83 CopyRight©2007-2010 by Homepage: http://www.21shtrade.com
I would never disagree with that. Arrogance is definitely apart of individualistic culture of America. I would however like to point out the fact that this thought of superiority probably happens in every country to a certain extent. It is often masked as Nationalism.
Wholesale 2010 Ladies and Men Garment, Clothing, Shoes, Caps, Sunglasses: Homepage: http://www.21shtrade.com
Topbrandswholesale Wholesale and Retail Nike series shoes available:
Air Force1, Air max, Air Yeezy, Nike Dunk, Nike Free, Nike Run, Nike Blazer, Nike Rift, Nike James, Nike Kobe, Nike Football, etc
Original packaging with all cards and tags
Big discount for big orders!! Your satisfaction is our goal!!
If you are interested in any of our products, please contact us for details or to place your special orders.
Reach us
Contact Person: Mr Tony (GM)
Email:shtradetony@hotmail.com or shtradevivien@hotmail.com
MSN ID: shtradetony@hotmail.com or shtradevivien@hotmail.com
Yahoo ID: tonycs1978@yahoo.com
Skype ID: shtradetony83 CopyRight©2007-2010 by Homepage: http://www.21shtrade.com
All nations before him are as nothing; and they are counted to him less than nothing, and vanity. (Isaiah 40:17)
I’m not from America, but I think your country is pretty much better than most countries in the world.
As a Canadian, yes, you guys do think, without a doubt, you’re better than everything else in existence. A piece of humble pie would do you good. There are many other contributors to humanity than the United States. Start with Great Britain, and make your way around the world, arriving at the US last.
Times are changing. I think it also doesn’t help that foreigners typically tend to have this unrealistic fantasy about the Americans and the country that we live in. A little advice: If you haven’t lived there, you probably don’t have a clue what it’s like.
http://www.goososo.comThe website wholesale for many kinds of fashion shoes, like the nike,jordan,prada, also including the jeans,shirts,bags,hat and the decorations. All the products are free shipping, and the the price is competitive, http://www.goososo.com a leading worldwide wholesaler company (or u can say organization). We supply more than 100 thousand high-quality merchandise and famous brand name products all at wholesale prices. Start your wholesale sourcing here today and experience first class service and fast shipping.yht
If America is so great then how come people over there can’t stop waxing nostalgic about ‘the Old Country’? America is no better or worse than any other developed democracy.
Come on, most countries believe they’re better than all the others. We’re not the only ones.
But we’re a pretty self-hating country, I think.
Notice how a lot of people who don’t live in the U.S. are talking about how much it sucks.
It may be that they think their own countries are better.
And there’s nothing wrong with that! It’s called nationalism, it just works at varying degrees.
This idea that people shouldn’t believe one person/place/thing/idea is better than another- just different- needs to stop. Sometimes, things ARE better. Not everything is right, not everything is equal.
@Frodoholic - I don’t recall saying that America was perfect. As far as slavery goes, you should keep in mind that the slave-trade started in America during the reign of George I while America was a collection of English colonies; the Founding Fathers of this country inherited the problem of slavery from England, so it makes sense that England should lead the way in ending that evil; once slavery became entrenched in society, it was very difficult to remove… in fact, 500,000 Americans lost their lives in the Civil War getting rid of slavery.
Health care is not a right. I reject your premise on this.
So far as gay marriage goes, I consider that an oxymoron, and I am not personally interested in redefining the meaning of words or undoing our culture’s traditions to pursue that particular choice because I believe it will be detrimental to the foundation of our society, which is the family. However, you are free to promote it if you like… I just won’t be joining you.
@www21shtradecom - Get off Xanga you spam whore.
I was taught to hate myself and that I didn’t deserve anything. I had a “false sense of entitlement.” But the things I needed, weren’t provided for at all, so later when other people who got something for being black or whatever, I was like, wtf? I didn’t get shit, had to work for nothing, blah,blah, but I didn’t realize it because of cliche arguments. It’s like not posting my comments on this other place. They wanted me to be open, so they can fucking post them.
I want to burn America to the ground and start over with logical arguments. Octavia.
I just want control, to rule the world.
I like times in America like the 1950s, but this rub in your face of crap is making me psychotic and beyond suicidal. Die-destroy.
I stand alone so alone I shall prevail!
I have a problem…
Funny I just watched a documentary by John Stossel on this. He says that we do think America is superior, but we might not actually be the best. They say Hong Kong is pretty up there in success. Also, Australia has a higher life expectancy, gdp per capita, literacy rate and a lower infant mortality rate.
I don’t. But I think many Americans do and shouldn’t.
I’m indifferent
@Jamie_Nip - I have to correct you on a few of your points. We’re not as generous with foreign aid as you might think. In 1970, the world’s rich countries agreed to give 0.7% of their gross national income as official international development aid, annually. Since that time, despite billions given each year, rich nations have rarely met their actual promised targets. For example, the US is often the largest donor in dollar terms, but ranks amongst the lowest in terms of meeting the stated 0.7% target.
In 1970, the world’s rich countries agreed to give 0.7% of their gross national income as official international development aid, annually. Since that time, despite billions given each year, rich nations have rarely met their actual promised targets. For example, the US is often the largest donor in dollar terms, but ranks amongst the lowest in terms of meeting the stated 0.7% target.
The United States may be ahead of the game when it comes to riches, but as for being green, it takes a step behind developing countries.In a 2009 Greendex survey, National Geographic and Globescan found that The U.S. ranks as the least environmentally sustainable country of the 17 surveyed.
Love it or Leave it? Why not?? I’ll tell you why not….
Our founding fathers were not “love it or leave it” people.
Thomas Jefferson did not tell everyone in the colonies with the Declaration of Independence to leave the oppressive tax regime of England and move to the unsettled and ungoverned far west. In fact, Thomas Jefferson went one step further by saying in the declaration:
”…Whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness.”
Jefferson did not simply wish you to stay and change the laws of your government. If necessary, the people should “abolish it, and [to] institute new Government.” I can express this idea in a similar sentence. The government should respect the wishes of its people or leave.
If I had the financial means to move out of the US, I’d do it in a millisecond.
I’m not proud to call myself an American, in fact, I don’t even call myself one. Until I obtain citizenship in another nation, and renounce my US citizenship, I will consider myself a stateless person.
Yes, you American super-patriots think your shit don’t stink, or at the very least, that it stinks less than everyone else’s and said attitude is awful. America is so blah, and I totally and completely agree with everything @puella_sapiens216 has to say.
@JosephParsons - Sorry to disapoint you, but the Civil War wasn’t just about “ending” slavery. In fact, Lincoln said he’d keep slavery if it meant preserving the union.
We might not be setting the best examples but yes, I do believe we are better. I have no facts to support my reasonings and I do believe many other countries set a better example than we do and take care of their citizens better but I am an American and damn proud.
Yes, completely, and it’s sick. America is definitely one of the richest countries in the world, but that by no means makes it superior. Economics is not the only thing to take into consideration, and many countries would say that we have terrible morals. This of course is up to opinion, but the very fact that we’re so closed-minded that we think we’re better than any other culture takes off major points in my book.
I would just like to comment that “loving your country” and recognizing her faults are not mutually exclusive concepts. Pointing out that particular things might be handled better in other lands doesn’t mean you hate the nation you were born and/or reside in.
@OhItWontBeForever - *LOL* Your comment just tickled me.
I was reading something about a British radio personality joking about the Queen’s death the other day. The article appeared on Yahoo! News and so of course was flooded by us Yanks. One of the first comments? “These guys need an editor. It’s spelled ‘apologize’!” *LOL* So quintessentially American, I love it :)
Yep, better than other countries but not as good as Germany.
@ithiliya - I would have laughed hard if I saw that, too!
it’s funny that Texas would have this since they produced one of the worst president in American history.
Depends on your part of the country. I’ve always felt it’s obnoxiously hip to blame American too much.
But the Texas board folks are looking to sanitize history in utterly dishonest ways.
@Frodoholic - Not a problem. I’m very rarely disappointed. I don’t recall saying that the Civil War was only about ending slavery… in fact there were quite a few reasons for the Civil War, slavery being one, agrarian vs. industrial economics being another, and western expansion being a third. This certainly does not diminish the cost of those lives which preserved the Union, ended slavery, and forced the south to begin the process of industrialization, all three of which served to advance a freer America and expand all sorts of civil and human rights, most curiously, women’s rights (industrialization). By the way, on the origins of English slavery, if we included corporate charters, it’s even older that George I… all the way back to 1672, Charles II.
Lol. That’s not American Exceptionalism. Its called Ethnocentrism and Americans are the best at it.
Yes, America should be taught to American children as the greatest country in the world. One should be taught the rights and responsibilities of being lucky enough to be born here and considered a citizen. They should be taught all of our glowing history and warned against our mistakes. To point out only the bad, to set America down as just another country is to rob the joys of National Pride from youth who no longer pledge allegiance in schools and to hurt the unity that has MADE us the best place in the world.
If I didn’t love the USA and think it’s better than all the rest, I wouldn’t be living here.
We tend to think so because we’re told so. I mean, the first order of business during school is to pledge allegiance to our flag.
I haven’t traveled out of this country (yet), so I can’t really know, can I?
It’s not that I necessarily dislike this country, but I’m amazingly frustrated by the people who think that any sort of criticism of America means you’re a traitor who wants to see America fall to the Commies.
Yes we do. I think there are plenty of ways in which we are…our Constitution is an amazing document and the freedoms and rights we acknowledge are quite exceptional. Not saying that there aren’t other good countries out there but I do love America, flaws and all. I’ve traveled to Mexico, Argentina, and Great Britain (which I know, isn’t much) and I still have the same opinion of America.
I think most countries tend to view themselves as best. I don’t look down on anyone for loving their own country.
I have read some pretty nice Russian textbooks, and thus was able to compare Russian world history to US world history, and when you read them, you’ll realise one stunning thing: Russia, the antagonist of everyone, sees things distinctly different from the USA. Who won WWII? Consult a Russian textbook, they’ll tell you they were the top contributor to the end of WWII. The USA will try to tell you they ended it, and will leave out Russia. Russia mentions the US + Japan, with some good ol’ Russian propaganda. Despite the bias, I’d much rather consult a Russian textbook, because it’s similar to all of Europe’s textbooks. The American textbooks are very, very strange; it almost reads like lies and bias and propaganda. And that’s what a USA history text is: propaganda. My opinion is that it’s black propaganda. Some people say it’s good, though.
As far as the best country to live in, or the best country of them all, I would not say there is a “best” but I wouldn’t say the USA is the best even if there is one. I’m rather patriotic (despite my ideology) but the flaws are there and obviously so. Every country has flaws. But the US is a country built up on propaganda; it’s what we DO. We are told as children we are the best, and we are blind to the propaganda shoved down our tiny trachea.
While I would love to write an unbiased history of the world, I feel I would be too biased to Germany and Russia.
There is a nice thing about not censoring video games, though, that gives the USA bonus points. But there is a joke stemming from the USSR: “An American and a Soviet meet up at Red Square. The American said ‘America is great, we can go out in our square and badmouth our president and no one will arrest us!’ The Soviet replies, ‘I can go out in our square and badmouth your president, too, and not get arrested.’” It’s all about perspective; I digress.
@JosephParsons - Well you said 50,000 died to end slavery, and I wonder just how many of them went into battle thinking they’re fighting against slavery.Let’s be realistic instead of idealisitc- most people were not abolitionist or considered blacks equal to them. It’s revitionist to insist we fought the war to end the horrible practice of slavery- since afterwards, it took a very, very long time to garauntee blacks and other minorities the civil rights you claim America is so known for.
@Frodoholic - I said 500,000 actually. I also said the Civil War was fought for a number of reasons including slavery, not that slavery was the sole reason. As for the abolitionist movement, I believe their actual numbers were in the tens of thousands, North and South, and I seem to recall about 60% of the public being sympathetic to that view. More so in the North of course, slavery was universally looked upon as ‘un-Christian.’ Changing the laws are naturally easier than changing hearts, so it is true, additional time was needed to end segregation. Nonetheless, that was done, and racial acceptance has likely never been greater in this country. I expect this trend to continue.
@Jessa1155 - I did not mean to infer the US was #1 in all of the areas mentioned, but more so that they are great contributions our citizens have made and continuously make. We may not be #1 in foreign aid assitance, but you can not deny we give massive amounts.
And I was not referring to the environmental green revolution, but the agricultural one that resulted in higher yeilding and stronger crops that saved starving people. Norman Borlaugh was one of the greatest humans to ever exist and is credited to saving a BILLION lives. He’s one of those “selfish, egotisitcal” Americans.
And I wouldn’t suggest anyone view our country as perfect and make no attempt to change government or legislation. I just have extreme frustration with people who say things along the lines of this is one of the worst countries ever and they basically hate everything about it. There’s a huge difference between people who can’t stand living here versus wishing some things would change. Believe me, there are more then a few things about this country that upset me, but never to the point to say such things as “I hate it here.” It just sounds childish and incredibly ungrateful, I guess. If one believes the way of life in this country is irreversibly terrible, as many people seem to be implying, I don’t understand why they would stay here.
Individualism is one of the, if not the most, prevelant driving forces of this country. That is what has lead our citizens to accomplishing so many great things. That’s one of the reasons I love living here. I would prefer that this not be reversed.
@Jamie_Nip - I get your point.. I just think even slightly inferring to support the “Love it or Leave It” concept is dangerous.
Now, onto your comments concerning the AGRICULTURAL “Greening Revolution”.
I think the more appropriate term would be the “The Agrichecmical Revolution”. I’m assuming you’re aware of Norman Borlaugh’s connection and support of genetically modified organisms? My criticism is not so much aimed at the man himself, but for the
biotech legacy he played a massive role in creating. After all, this
was the man who arguably did more than any other to nurture the era of
GM foods and the intensive use of petrochemical pesticides
and fertilizers. He may well have saved a billion people from imminent
starvation, but by doing so he also inadvertently
helped to plant the seed for future environmental disaster. Borlaug’s “dwarf” hybrid seed varieties, when coupled with
the heavy fertilizer and pesticide doses they need to thrive,
dramatically increased yields in the places where the Green Revolution
took root—the main success story being India.
But higher yields
drive down crop prices—and increased use of imported inputs requires the
taking on of debt. Rather than boosting the fortunes of most farmers in
its purview, the Green Revolution drove hundreds of thousands into
ruin. The survivors consolidated land holdings. The big got bigger and
the poor tended to leave the land—too many of them ending up as excess
labor in urban slum zones.
GMOs also lead to monster agribusiness companies such as Monsanto.
This is coming from someone with considerable knowledge on the subject… I buy NOTHING with GMO ingredients for my family and am heavily involved in the support of community supported agriculture and the Slow Food movement.
How supportive was Borlaugh on eco-friendly organic farming methods? I quote:
“Don’t tell the world that we can feed the present population without
chemical fertilizer. That’s when this misinformation [about the merits
of organic farming] becomes destructive.”~ Borlaugh
If you doubt the dangers of GMOs and companies such as Monsanto I suggest you watch “The World According to Monsanto”~
http://topdocumentaryfilms.com/the-world-according-to-monsanto/
Monsanto’s controversial
past combines some of the most toxic products ever sold with misleading
reports, pressure tactics, collusion, and attempted corruption. They now race
to genetically engineer (and patent) the world’s food supply, which
profoundly threatens our health, environment, and economy. Combining
secret documents with first-hand accounts by victims, scientists, and
politicians, this widely praised film exposes why Monsanto has
become the world’s poster child for malignant corporate
influence in government and technology.
“There’s nothing they are leaving untouched: the mustard, the okra, the bringe oil, the rice, the cauliflower. Once they have established the
norm: that seed can be owned as their property, royalties can be
collected. We will depend on them for every seed we grow of every crop
we grow. If they control seed, they control food, they know it – it’s
strategic. It’s more powerful than bombs.”
This movie, in addition to the film “FOOD INC”, changed my life… I will never look at food the same way again.
@Jessa1155 - Typo correction~ “Agrochemical Revolution”
@tholianweb - My point was that the “american ideals” may not be ideal for everyone else. Sure, some things will easily be favored by people of all countries; you’re right in that most people don’t like tyranny. But what about the gray areas? What about capitalism? Some people prefer a more socialistic system where you get a college education for only 320 euros a year (this is a specific example for a friend of mine in France).
I consider myself a patriot. I come from a long line of officers in various branches of the military and i am PROUD to be an american. BUT. Not everyone needs to value the same things that I do, and who are we to push those ideals on other people?
@puella_sapiens216 - Serbians are just mad because America did not just sit back and watch them as they tortured, raped, and killed innocent people in Kosovo and Bosnia.
@Jessa1155 - I believe I originally said “love it or leave it” was an over the top statement, but that’s beside the point.
Ok, this is one of those topics where one side is never going to concede to the other, but here goes:
You can afford to eat organic. If I bought all organic food, I couldn’t have made rent. You have that option, and you should be very thankful you do. But unless you and yours are starving, I don’t believe it’s right to tell people what they should and shouldn’t eat or presume you know what’s best for them. If using GM foods and pesticides means people in the third world have access to more food, it will never be my place to tell them that food isn’t good enough.
Food being LESS expensive is a good thing. People can then spend the money they didn’t spend on organic for things like educating their children or more adequate shelter. There was a point in time where ALL food was organic. We had less people, and more people were starving. Enough with the romanticism of peasant life. People are urbanizing in order to increase their standard of living, not because they had to leave their awesome lives that included back-breaking farming methods and living in rural shacks.
If all of the current farms went organic, we could only feed 2/3 of the planet. I don’t see any volunteers. If you want to eat all organic, that’s your choice, and it’s awesome you stick with your convictions to eat more natural food. The organic food industry is a multi-billion dollar a year industry and is continuously growing. I don’t anticipate it going anywhere any time soon. But I find it incredibly wrong that people who have access to Trader Joe’s are telling others who have much less then them why the foods they’re eating to survive aren’t good enough or that they shouldn’t use them. So do we just ban all pesticides, outlaw GM foods, and fire everyone who works for large agricultural businesses? What’s the appropriate course of action without killing people and driving up food costs in the name of sticking it to a food company?
I haven’t seen that particular documentary, but I have watched The Future of Food. I had to watch it in a hospitality management class because my teacher believed it was important to know “where the food in our industry comes from.” I knew there was another side because I come from a family involved in agriculture. My grandparents were some of those helpless people under the mind control of a large corporation who used Monsanto products.
I believe very passionately in furthering science and making food much more accessible to all people, even if that involves genetic experiments and the use of pesticides. Genetics of plants evolve over time anyways through selective breeding and grafting. It’s not a big deal. And surprise, I’m not being paid off by Monsanto or any other large agricultural business.
I think we got off topic haha
IT’S NOT A BIG DEAL!??
I’m appalled that you’re standing in defense of a company that has killed MILLIONS of people with it’s toxic and deadly products… for profit.
Another HUGE misconception about organic foods (one of many you seem to have) is that it’s an elitist movement. I would almost guarantee my budget is more restrictive than yours. I have a disabled child, an newborn and three adults to support on ONE adult income. I grow my own food and do work for food trade with a local organic farm. I spend FAR less on food than the average family. I would never presume to tell anyone else how to eat. It’s advocates of GMOs that are doing that job. If farmers and other countries are so happy with Monsanto ( and the other big AG companies) why do they have a reputation as being the most evil company in history?
Do you know ho many small family farmers have lost EVERYTHING to that company? If your family is involved in agriculture, I’d be shocked to hear you approve of that company. I think out of all the people I’ve spoken to on this subject you are the first.
And “presume to know what’s best” for the rest of the world’s agriculture is exactly what Monsanto has done! They are not a charitable organization. They profit off the backs of the hungry and those people live enslaved by their toxin-infested seeds. It’s pure arrogance to think humans can outwit mother nature. In the grand scheme of agricultural history GMOs are relatively new, the first whole food GMO crop grown in the US was a tomato variety in 1994. The jury is still out on the health implications. Round Up IS a toxic chemical. It is well established that healthy soils produce healthy crops,
healthy animals, and healthy people. Research and development should
focus on agricultural methods, including organic, which recycle
nutrients to build soil health, producing abundant yields of nutrient
dense foods, while protecting environmental resources. To
date, recombinant genetic modification has contributed to the
development of herbicide-resistant weeds and an increase in the
application of synthetic fertilizers and pesticides, with associated
increases in soil erosion and water contamination, while producing foods
with lower nutritional content. Technologies, such as genetic
engineering, which foster moncropping are not compatible with organic
systems, where soil-building crop rotations are required.
Since you’re so passionate about science and progress, perhaps I’ll quote a couple of ground-breaking scientists for you?
“The trouble with a mandate for GM crops is this: it won’t work. A
recent report by the Union of Concerned Scientists demonstrates that GM
crops don’t increase crop yields. USAID has already spent millions of
taxpayer dollars developing GM crops over the past two decades, without a
single success story to show for it, and plenty of failures. A recent,
highly touted partnership between USAID and Monsanto to develop a
virus-resistant sweet potato in Kenya failed to deliver anything useful
for farmers. After 14 years and $6 million, local varieties vastly
outperformed their genetically modified cousins in field trials. Another
10-year USAID project for GM eggplant in India recently met with such
outcry — from scientists and Indian farmers alike — that the
government
put a moratorium on its release. Growing insect resistance to
genetically modified cotton and corn shows that the technology is
already failing farmers and will continue to fail over the long term.
Sadly, today’s GM obsession shows every indication of duplicating the
first ill-fated “Green Revolution” that trapped millions of farmers on a
pesticide treadmill while devastating the functioning of the ecosystems
on which we depend. Fortunately, we have alternatives. Improved
farming practices, conventional breeding and agro-ecological techniques
deliver far better results, without the risks and high input costs that
accompany GM seeds.”
Monsanto’s history has long drawn ire from environmentalists, health
advocates and small farmers, going back to its production of Agent
Orange during the Vietnam war. Exposure to Agent Orange has caused
cancer in an untold number of US veterans, and the Vietnamese government
claims that 400,000 Vietnamese people were killed or disabled by Agent
Orange, and 500,000 children were born with birth defects as a result of
their exposure. Some gift, eh??
Did you know that Haiti has committed to burning Monsanto seed?
If these GMOs are such a gift, why would a country is such desperate need of assistance turn away 475 TONS of seed?
“Fighting hybrid and GMO seeds is critical to save our diversity and our
agriculture,” Jean-Baptiste said in an interview in February. “We have
the potential to make our lands produce enough to feed the whole
population and even to export certain products. The policy we need for
this to happen is food sovereignty, where the county has a right to
define it own agricultural policies, to grow first for the family and
then for local market, to grow healthy food in a way which respects the
environment and Mother Earth.”
http://www.truthout.org/haitian-farmers-commit-burning-monsanto-hybrid-seeds59616
This stuff may be “no big deal” to you.. but to some of us it’s a huge cause we fight for everyday.
@Jamie_Nip -
I forgot to mention…
Watch the movie online for free, you might be surprised how quickly your thinking on this subject will change. It is indeed a very, very BIG DEAL.
http://twilightearth.com/environment-archive-2/the-world-according-to-monsanto-full-documentary/
@albaangel - Serbians (and other people) have a problem seeing American forces try to be the world’s police and trying to start a new sort of imperialism. This is also the same for the whole situation in the Middle East – America is still pouring in soldiers to control it.
I believe that if America wasn’t sticking its huge ugly nose into other countries’ business, they’d be fine. Wars and conflicts should only be resolved by those countries directly involved. I don’t think any other countries have a right to intervene, especially the US.
@Jessa1155 - Again, so what do we do? Eliminate all GM plants and make pesticides illegal? Make research illegal? What is a practical course of action that wouldn’t involve starving people or driving up food costs? If people wish to use them, shouldn’t they be allowed? If you don’t want to use Monsanto, that’s fine, but many people do. Maybe other countries don’t take these food because their governments are consistently told by environmentalist groups and other people who aren’t starving that they’ll be “poisoned” by these foods.
These sites will probably be dismissed by these people having an “agenda” but I promise you I’ve looked at both sides of the argument. Both sides are backed up by reputable scientists, and both sides have opportunity to be taken advantage of by political movements. Monsanto is not the only entity doing genetic work with foods. Universities and agricultural scientists all around the world are looking for ways to improve food production without the incentive for “corporate greed.” Fight the patenting process, fight the legal process, demand monetary settlement for people who were intentionally or unintentionally given failed crops, but don’t fight research. The scientific process IS met with failures, but also so much progress. To demand that we stop research in food advancement because we have the opportunity to be picky with our food isn’t fair at all.
http://www.cnn.com/2010/OPINION/04/13/specter.denying.science/index.html <one of the best speeches i’ve ever heard. also discusses vaccines.
http://www.breadandbutterscience.com/Fear32.htm
Or here, the world health organization!
http://www.who.int/foodsafety/publications/biotech/20questions/en/index.html
“GM foods currently available on the international market have passed risk assessments and are not likely to present risks for human health. In addition, no effects on human health have been shown as a result of the consumption of such foods by the general population in the countries where they have been approved. Continuous use of risk assessments based on the Codex principles and, where appropriate, including post market monitoring, should form the basis for evaluating the safety of GM foods.”
The FDA approves GM foods. They are extensively tested. How is that not good enough? Or can we only possess distrust in a government entity when it doesn’t provide a service we believe in?
Again I’m not going to change your mind on the subject, and my mind won’t be changed either. I really don’t have a problem with eating GM foods, and I’d prefer that right is not taken away from more people than it has been. You say you’re not telling people how to eat, but it sounds like you want to dismantle the production of GM foods.
@AubreyBird - I agree that we shouldn’t push them on others. But we don’t have the monopoly on that by far. But some systems work better empirically. Speaking of France, if we think our unemployment is bad, its nothing compared to what theirs is on a regular basis. woof lol
@Jamie_Nip -
Wow, for someone who hasn’t even watched the movie you’re unflinching in your position. You say you’ve listened to both sides of the argument yet I have the distinct impression you’re arguing simply for the sake of wanting to be right. Because nobody in their right mind would condone the actions of a company such as Monsanto without being ignorant of their actions.
You come back again and again with information in support of GMos (quoted from Codex no less), yet say nothing about the horrors committed by Monsanto. GMOs may or may not have had some practical applications but when a genetically modified organism is created for the sole purpose of selling a toxic product such as Round-Up ( a diluted version of Monsanto’s fist and most profitable product Agent Orange) it’s potential for good is dead on arrival. I may not believe in GMOs but if they ARE going to be used, developed and peddled to third world countries it should not be in the name of profit.( **** THAT IS AS CLOSE TO AN AGREEMENT YOU’LL GET FROM ME AND I REALLY TRIED TO FIND ONE.)
I’d prefer the science on the world’s dinner-plate to be provided by someone I trust….someone NOT synonymous with death and destruction. Right now 60% of processed foods are infested with Monsanto GMO products. They don’t feel you have the right to know which products but if they have non-organic soy, you’re eating GMOs. IF GMOs are so safe, why do they refuse to label the products? Maybe because they know most Americans, when given a choice, will avoid them. Do you even remember what happened with Monsanto’s bovine growth hormone? The FDA approved that too, without labeling, with the help of government officials tied directly to Monsanto’s purse-strings.The FDA approves it, it HAS to be safe, right? Do you know how large a company Monsanto is? Their power reaches into government, lobbyists and yes, even the FDA. Secretary of Agriculture Tom Vilsack used to WORK for Monsanto! Go do some research on how many connections the company has in our government. Power corrupts, absolute power corrupts absolutely.
How do you fight Monsanto without fighting the research when Monsanto OWN IT ALL.. research, scientist, seed patents. agrochemicals. ALL OF IT!?
You use these terms “poisoned”, “corporate greed” in quotes, as if these are fanatical concepts. I work with farmers whom live and breathe these topics everyday. I see with my own eyes the devastating impact it’s had that farmers can be sued for saving seeds, a right our forefathers would never have imaged we’d lose.So, the 600 farmers Monsanto has sued, put out business and left penniless…. did they deserve to be prosecuted by Monsanto?? I wonder if it had been your family they dragged through the mud if you’d feel any differently. OF COURSE you would:(
But hey, all in the name of science and advancement, at all or any cost obviously.
You have the enthusiasm of someone on the debate team…. who just wants to win the debate. I’ve read those links you gave me. Until you’ve done some research and truly listened to both sides of this argument I can’t stand this anymore. I’m aware of the other sides position. I’m not one of those feverish PETA types who bash other people for how they live their lives. I’m actually quite moderate in my views in most instances. But this is not an area I will bend on. I don’t go through hell to make sure my kids eat safe, organic foods due to some whimsical ideal.
I’ve never met someone, without a personal connection to Big-Ag, who continues to deflect the questions posed about Monsanto with the ability to sway the conversation in another direction… with the ease of a well-rehearsed politician.
Monsanto is a greed-driven entity with blood on it’s hands. They don’t deserve your loyalty or your trust. You’re obviously an intelligent person. I truly hope you rethink your position and watch the movie or read some unbiased literature on the subject. Michael Pollan would be a great place to start.
All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing.Edmund BurkeSorry for getting totally off-topic and hi-jacking your post Dan!:)
@puella_sapiens216 -
Well some countries are not fortunate enough to have a strong military or enough money or power to protect themselves. So does that mean that they can be controlled and try to be taken over by violence and force? The U.S. saw that what the Serbs were doing to these people is wrong and decided to help. There is nothing wrong with that. They helped a country that was incapable of helping themselves to do what was right.
@tholianweb - but if you ask a french person, they would disagree and bring up how much americans pay for school and health care, blah blah blah. trust me; i am in france right now. lol. mais c’est amusant.
@AubreyBird - lol – it is nice that they get “free” schoolin’. to bad their unemployment is worse than ours – but the unemployment problem they face has nothing to do with the “free” school, granted, but many of the other laws they have pretty much are the cause. a “free” degree is great, but if you cant get a job, it is rendered useless. of course, they could always just give people more “free” stuff so they can survive, but at what point do people start to question the practicality of their system? of course we can have unemployed people here with degrees, but here we call them philosophers and artists ^^ lol
@albaangel - Well, its like they say. A friend in need is a friend indeed. Of course, when they don’t need us, we are evil incarnate. Everyone hates the “rich” guy until they want to borrow his money.
Will always have their important dreams forever! Also believe in yourself!
By <a href=" http://www.airjordans.cc/air-jordan-12-12/">Jordan Jordan Retro 12
<a href="http://www.airjordans.cc/air-jordan-4-4/">Jordan Jordan Retro 4
The Thomas Sabo necklace and other jewellery lines are aimed at both women and men. This is part of the large success of this high quality silver jewellery. There is a little something for everybody no matter what their taste. Part of being successful in the jewellery business is being able to cater to a very wide audience.One of the most endearingly popular products is the charm necklace. You can choose a necklace or a bracelet to adorn with multiple decorative charms, and there are plenty out there to choose from. These charms come from every interest and aspect of life that you can think of. Everyone can have a necklace that reflects their individual taste and experiences. In today’s society, we are into being unique and showing others who we are. This is the great thing about the thomas sabo schmuck and charm line.All necklaces and bracelets are sterling silver of the highest quality. Depending on the length of the Thomas Sabo anhänger , it has many different weights. You can start at around dhs80 in price and work up to dhs250.