November 19, 2012

  • Would Christmas Be Better Without the Gifts?

    About 45% of Americans say they would rather skip Christmas.  One of the main reasons is the financial strain Christmas brings.
    People borrow money or put gifts on credit cards that they feel they can’t afford.  Here is the link:  Link
    Do you think Christmas would be better without the gifts?
                                                                              

Comments (45)

  • one of my family members uses the money she would have spent on a gift to buy a goat for a needy family in an undeveloped country.  I can’t remember the name of the organization but she’s been doing this for years.  I’d actually like to start doing that instead of giving gifts. 

  • One year when we were kids, my sisters and I, instead of buying presents for each other, bought presents to donate to children in need. We filled a shoebox each as part of a church mission. I can’t say that this was our idea, and at first we weren’t into it. But our parents were teaching us not only gratefulness for what we had but also the gift of giving. It was one of the top two Christmases I remember now as an adult. Christmas would not be better without gifts. Christmas would be better without greed.

  • I think life would be better without people stupidly wasting money in general.

  • Here I come with the obvious answer, Yes, because perhaps our focus would be re directed to the Gift of God Who started Christmas in the first place.

  • Good question. Kids love getting Christmas gifts but they learn it’s a time they will get gifts. If kids didn’t learn that there’d be no expectation. Still, here we are and it’s great to see smiles on the faces of kids. After growing into adulthood I’ve enjoyed buying and giving gifts more than getting them. I love the comments above about spending money instead for a needy family and kids spending money to donate to children in need. 

  • I grew up in a home that didn’t celebrate Xmas…. I married someone who did…. The only reason I celebrate it now is because I like the family unity there is around that time of the year… I dont new physical gifts…. If a person can give me happiness and or a few nights of laughter unity and care I’ll be happy… I hope to give The same in return 

  • lol xmas isn’t about gifts, we don’t give presents to each other, just some for the children but grown ups just gather together to spend time as a family and eat lots and lots of candies.

  • I think if we tone down the expectations we could keep the gift giving and still enjoy the holiday.

  • @saintvi -  Agree’d!   I’ve always enjoyed the getting together of families more than gift giving/receiving.

  • @light_blue_fables - How odd. MY sister buys a family and sends it to a needy goat! Hmm.

  • I stopped expecting presents in high school, but I’ve come to realize that they’re pretty pointless. When you’re little and you rely on toys to have fun it’s different. As an adult if I want something badly enough I can just get it for myself.

  • I buy myself gifts nearly every week starting from January every year, so when the holidays roll around, I won’t expect gifts, because it’ll just show just how inconsiderate the people have been the entire year leading up to the holidays. I pretty much have everything that I want and can buy for myself. I mainly like personalized gifts or cards. I’m sentimental and have kept cards and other memorabilia since kindergarten. I’ll spend all my money on  myself. they don’t have to spend money on me and nor do I have to spend on them. a christmas card is just as welcome. not an e-card. a real paper card with handwritten notes inside.

  • No… we only buy what we can afford. end of story. people should try it =]

  • I love giving gifts to children and babies.   

  • I ain’t gonna lie, Christmas would be better if Taylor Lautner was in a box under the tree for me.  

  • In our family the adults don’t buy gifts for each other. We only buy for the kids (and there are only four of them in total). We’ve done the Christmas without gits, the “only-handmade-gifts”, etc. stuff.  I enjoy what Sarahsmurfette said. Somehow we just get caught up in all the commercialism.  However, it remains a joy to see my kids’ faces light up when ”Father Christmas” gives them what they asked for.  (Besides, that’s one of the greatest bribing tools ever:  If you’re not a good boy, you won’t get that soccer ball you want…) Here in South Africa, the government has plans underfoot to de-holiday Christmas time, so that it will no longer be a public holiday. Now there’s a thought! Would Christians then actually take the time and make the effort (and sign a few days’ leave) to celebrate the Greatest Gift – or would it become just another day?

  • YES!!! I don’t say yes because of financial reasons, but rather I would like it much more if my family, instead of giving meaningless objects, decided to get together and learn more about one another. I’m tired of the shallowness in my family. I want a change this christmas. not some stupid gift.

  • the spirit of giving should be celebrated every day of the year. we don’t have to buy presents or waste money on these material items. we only need to give friendship, give trust, give faith, give forgiveness, give love, and all good things to those we claim to care about. even to those we do not know, we can give kindness. sometimes giving material items are important. give a jacket to someone who is without a jacket. give a blanket. if not comfortable sharing money, to go a convenience store and buy bottles of water and give them to the beggars. its not about Christmas. its about giving and making the world a better place for someone else, even a total stranger.

  • most probably.  it’ll allow people to focus more on the idea of being with their family than getting something in return.  presents should be optional.

  •          Dear Theologian Cafe: I was one of those children on Christmas morning who woke up to the absolute dread of waking up to the blessing of, “No gifts,” on Christmas morning, and I find little character building from the realization of our poverty. Those of us of Judeo Christian origin are reminded that the Gospels do not even speak of the birth of the Christ without knowing that gifts were a part of the Christmas which some like to think of as the essence of Christian’ s  leap of faith that something miraculous happened more than 2000 years ago, and we accept the pleasure of the tale of Kings bearing gifts, for they had watched the heaves and waited for the signs of a Christ Child — God as man to be born.  I do not consider the people at the time to be unlearned, quite to the contrary, that for around what would be heading toward six thousand years before — That ancient scrolls had told beautifully that a Christ would come among us as man, and they had no distraction from studying the astrology, and what so many wish to believe was a case of full blown mythology, began to record what man could expect in the known world at the time.Can you imagine how, in that known world, when all the signs and visions began to come to fruition what joy these people of their tribes, their time, and the known world must have felt;  When everything came together in the heavens and on earth and the  exquisite persona of Mary had been asked would she bring forth God as man, and let him fullfill all of the ancient prophecy which they had been waiting for in the Jewish world for what is now heading into the 6000 year mark of such prophecy.  The scholars at the time from area to area continued to move from The Old Testament and on in to the new where we still have much prophecy before us.  It is with full heart in which we allow ourselves to be drawn in to the experience of Christmas year after year, and many Protestant groups do not even accept the Old Testament as anything but the preparation for what was to come.Why would people not want to give gifts to one another and celebrate these days of Advent and then Christmas; For it takes us out of ourselves in to the joy of celebrating something so much bigger than us.  Prophecy is still considered to be a gift, but we cannot close out the noise of daily life to hear anything which is whispered to us.  I ache at the noise which closes out love and caring for one another.  Here we are though still watching, still waiting, and some of us are fully convinced that something  which has lasted over all of these years we can feel excited that, “A Spiritual King was born,” and part of the celebration includes the giving of gifts.  Unless we are diabled, even the poorest among us are capable of giving even if it is nothing but a love letter under the Christmas tree or on the days of Hannukah.  The generous heart seeks out to give as such those who have nothing will have something, and I wish that my parents could have understood that the smallest gifts meant so very much.My Dad could whittle for pleasure, could build our furniture when we had none, but come Christmas my dear parents always went on a depression spree, and instead of something Dad could have made for us like a little box or a doll, or our mother making a sock monkey, they usually wound up bursting at the seams and in a dangerous battle threatening to kill each other.  My Mom ould tell us she was thinking about poisoning our father’s coffee after my sisters and older brothers had gone on, and Mom would pounce, and the next thing we knew this strong man was beating her.I used to get excited when Dad had got some pencils and pens from a feed store, and in later years we were never without apples and oranges once Dad brought in a pay check.  Straight through my high school years though; they would get gifts from the older kids mailed home, but my chest would hurt endeavoring to hold in that no one would remember me.  We were a broken family, and I was dead in the center of their later, “Bunch,” as we were called, so I swore that when I made it the long way from them; I would do what they could not do for themselves and the elder children felt too financially fearful of losing what they had gained, so the end result is that I sit ordering gifts for everyone, for the joy of giving has not fully made its way into some of my siblings  hearts;  So good darned old privileged me.  “Christmas is just for kids”,and the abiding;; “Christmas is just for the kids!”It happens to some within my own family, that some do overspend, and you are so right;  Then people are in debt.  I wish they just understood that dollar store goods are just fine, and if anyone does not appreciate the gifts lovingly purchased for them at  Ts he Dollar General Store, then they are losing the idea of gifts in this beautiful season, that to be though of is sheer love.  Turn off the bloody TV, and let children get excited about a little car and truck, a little stuffed animal, and maybe even a new toothbrush.  It is absolutely stupid to charge up credit cards and to put yourself in debt.  In her later years, my mom wanted always to buy me something, and the last thing which I remember is a coffee mug which cost her fifty cents, and to this day that coffee mug is among my most precious gifts. I picked it out, and Mama bought it for me.  That was all it took to give a gift which made me very happy.Charging up gifts which you cannot pay for is hurtful to every family member, but it is most hurtful to the children who have to watch depressed parents coping poorly through the winter trying to make sense of why Mom and Dad are not happy.  I seriously believe there should be serious public servie announcements to help people understand they are doing no one any favor by purchasing what they cannot pay off.  Why is it that grown ups no longer are able to realize that their burden is everyone’s burden.  I mean it when I say that I am happy to get pictures of grand children, and that is present enough.  Here is where you beg the parents to know that using imagination and siting down and playing with their children with the toys they already have and have forgotten is means far more than spending on credit cards.Gifts have a great effect on the national economy, for we need those who can buy to do exactly that, for it is the beautiful stores golden weaks where they are making money to tide them over through the year.  Even if you have no religious fervor, if you have money; Please get out there and spend, spend, spend, for the merchants need the cash to keep people in jobs.  I strongly am impressed with an American toy company called, “Melissa and Doug,” and looking at things such as gifts from artist, and the, ever so faithful beloved food sources and bakeries; Oh Lord, plese may the 250,000 dollar club buy so many darned presents that they colapse the internets computers with disbelief.My husband is the ultimate unappreciative person when it comes to gifts, and on Christmas day, he packs all of his gifts in one  bag except for maybe a shirt or something he asked for, and he pouts and frets over other people’s spending.  He was a priviileged little boy though, so what we cannot do for him is to bring back his Christmas years of old when he was the center of attention.  One day, somtime, I will go in and get his Christmas bag and put the food in cupboards, and I will see what he might like to use after he is long past Holidays, and that in itself is a hurtful bunch of abuse which I have never shared with my children.  I do not share a lot over the Christmas Holidays, for it is difficult enough to keep the demons down who try to summon me to the table of remembrance which I put away as best that I can.So; Good Theologian; you get it! Christmas is sometimes hard, but those of us who had not greatly appreciate that someone remembered us; And Happy Holidays to the agnostics; But to all of you who still can view shepards and astronomers transfixed on a star which led them to the place where Jesus was born, then may you enjoy packages, for life goes quickly by us, and we can join the ancients in Celebration. So, “Merry Christmas to one and all,” but first enjoy Thanksgiving, among the lovliest of all days when we  must savor our journey to Christmas.  and in to the New Year when there is a chance — Just a chance that it may be the best year of our lives.  I am leaving a gift for you Mr. Theologian.Blessings, Barbara Everett Heintz, “{Pinkhoneysuckle” Award Winner in San Francisco and Hollywood Book Festivals — With a First Prize Award in Hollywood’s 2012 Book Festival — Amazon Book and Kindle Ready.

  • Our family is doing Christmas with minimal gifts this year!The plan is just enjoy a delicious dinner we make together on Christmas (cranberry sauce with red wine and maple syrup anyone?) and put up the tree together sometime around the 1st of December

  • Christmas would be better if people would set and stick with a budget. Gifts are a wonderful way to show people that you care about them. They are also a wonderful way to celebrate the prosperity capitalism has wrought in our country. That said, it’s logical to want to take it down a notch or two in our current economic climate, where capitalism seems like it’s on the way out. 

  • @light_blue_fables Probably WorldVision. My Grampa does that, too. I don’t mind, really. I like it better when I can choose what to give to them. I usually pick medicine or education.Gift giving at Christmastime would be better if most people remembered what giving gifts was all about. And it’s definitely not about the amount of $$$$$ spent.

  • It would bebso much better.

  • Gifts for kids, not for adults. 

  • we don’t do gifts except for under 18yrs old.

  • If people just stayed within their means they’d be fine.  

  • ~*Absolutely*~… first of all I am sick of the stores placing sales, items, and pressure before we can even get through Halloween!!! Now the news is saying that we should all shop instead of even having Thanksgiving?!?!?!  Secondly, I think Black Friday is entertainment for rich people!!! Think about it, first of all they can get people to sleep in a tent, rain/cold for a week, than the cameras catch all the drama of those busting in and acting like a dog fighting over a bone! Not to mention, the only deals are to those that slept in a tent, and others are mentally slow because they have the mentality “I stood in line, gonna buy something” and end up buying things they in their rational minds wouldn’t have! So rich people earn money hand over fist from people trying to get material things they obviously can’t afford to begin with on top of it all on video to play back… and news plays them… more like Jerry Springer without the “lust” and replaced by “greed”?!?!?! I would love to see Christmas return to being about time spent, bonding (instead of face in phones or computers), and Thanksgiving be about a day we can all be GRATEFUL and share that with those we love? Not sleeping in a tent for something you can’t afford, and if you can sit there a week do you even have a job (hence probably can’t afford what you think you need, priorities backwards)?

  • A Christmas without gifts is a Christmas without love which is no Christmas at all. Gifts are the only tangible evidence of love. If you truly love someone you’ll do what it takes to show that love, whether you have to go into debt, beg, borrow, steal, or commit acts of self degradation. Don’t kid yourself. If your so-called “loved ones” tell you they don’t have the money this year they don’t love you. If they did, they would have made the appropriate sacrifices to make sure you were taken care of at Christmas

  • I hate when people buy me stuff, so yes.

  • A good friend of mine gave out store bought gifts to certain people for all occassions, but her special friends always got something handmade, I consider myself lucky to be one of those and appreciate the thought she put into them.  That is the true spirit of “gift giving”.

  • We already have Christmas without gifts.  It’s called Thanksgiving.  Personally, I like shopping for people and thinking about each gift I give.  As for getting gifts – I prefer home made.

  • We have stopped giving gifts, and Christmas is just as enjoyable, mauybe more so because the stress of finding money for gifts is gone. 

  • Christmas would be better without God.

  • @Celestial_Teapot - umm – it would be more accurate to say that Christmas would not exist without God.  

  • We have gone to giving the gift of time – ie; we give my daughter and her husband a weekend where we watch their children. Last year we took a summer family vacation instead of Christmas gifts.  We have given the grand kids coupons for “sleepovers”.  We feel that time together is truly the best gift of all!

  • No one HAS to buy gifts. Money is tight at our house, and we don’t always buy or receive gifts. 

  • @AngelAsh_86 - Christmas should be about the happiness of children. Gifts don’t have to be expensive or bought to liven up their moods.

  • @roxics - “Gifts for kids, not for adults. “Yup. And nothing like a tickle-me-elmo to send mixed messages.

  • No. Christmas is a time of giving.  Giving doesn’t have to cost money. We can give ourselves to others. Our time is a precious gift.  Helping others in ways that meet their needs is so important and hopefully it will continue throughout the year and not just one day! 

  • As long we still have Christmas dinner. 

  • Christmas doesn’t have to be a financial strain, it’s just people tend to focus on giving/getting big expensive items. My friends and I have the best parties where give each other inexpensive items or home-made crafts as prezzies. I don’t think I have ever spent $100 on gifts for friends and family combined, let alone per person. The holidays should be about spending time with those you love, and not about how much you spend on them… it’s just nice to have something small to open, too.  SUMR

  • how about instead of “skipping Christmas” you get the people you love ONE thing that you think they will like and don’t make it a living room-full extravaganza.

  • Hi, I’m Tina, Dear i came across your profile and became interested in you. I would love to be your friend. Please write me at (tinazomba@yahoo.com) So we may know better.Do reach me via email at (tinazomba@yahoo.com) i await your reply. thanks

  • I’m confident that once you read this again you come to read these articles and blogs.beauty gift sets

Post a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *